@oralloy,
OK, I mentioned that I didn't like the proposal overall, but did like the proposed German modification.
The reason I don't like the proposal overall is because "land for peace" was supposed to give Israel the security of peaceful acceptance in exchange for giving up their land.
However, this deal threatens to have Israel give up their land without receiving any peaceful acceptance from the Palestinians in turn. Notice that in the article the Palestinians say that this EU deal is unacceptable to them:
Quote:But so far, the Palestinians oppose the European proposal and insist on advancing their own.
Quote:"Our insistence stems from one simple reason, which is that in every conversation we've had with the Americans and Europeans so far, we haven't heard a proposal that could meet the Palestinians' minimum demands," one said.
What will happen if this EU proposal passes the UN Security Council, and the Palestinians reject the proposal and refuse to make peace? Does Israel still have to give up the land even though they aren't getting peaceful acceptance from the Palestinians?
This same concern is also why I like the proposed German modification:
Quote:But there's an argument over whether the resolution should address the issue of Israel being the nation-state of the Jewish people -- a clause Germany is pushing to include.
If Israel is to give up any more land, they need to get full acceptance from the Palestinians in return, and that means acceptance of Israel as a Jewish state.