@tanguatlay,
Quote:He said that I'm a karate expert. I said that I cannot / could not be called one.
Which word should I use? I think 'cannot' is the right word because the fact remains that I consider myself to be not a karate expert.
Language is much more complicated that the simple rules, Tanguatlay. Why? Because life is complicated and there are many possible emotive responses that different speakers might/may want to express.
The fact that remains can/could be just as easily expressed by using either
could not or
cannot. Why? Because both
can and
could can/could be used to discuss future, present and past situations.
In this case, using
could not makes the response seem, 1) less forward/more deferential; 2) a simple backshift that illustrates reported speech.
We can really tell whether the use of
could not is 1) or 2) though we probably could if we were in the actual situation.