littlek wrote:
It is possible to be unaffiliated with the church and not have sex while maintaining one's health.
.
I agree, nothing I said contradicts this, however a person must be fairly spiritually advanced in order to do no sex well. A lot of people do it not so well.
If you believe however that the Church directed celibacy all of these years to the detriment of priests then you are very cynical indeed. How would the Church get away with that if it were true??? With-in a generation men of the church would have seen that the church teaching was wrong and would have corrected it. It held for so many centuries because those who came before them saw with their own experience that the teaching was correct.
The sex scandals with in the modern American Catholic Church is not due to the celibacy policy being wrong, it is due to a general weakness of the modern Church and well as a weakness in the men who are priests. The Priests having sex with the kids in the church, and the Church not fixing the problem, was due more to Vatican 2 then it was any other factor. Now the American Catholic Church is screwed, it is rapidly being drained of its financial resources and of its members.