Crossposted from Polls thread:
_________________________________
Republican primaries in California and New York
Update graphs with all polling from December and January on the Republican race in CA and NY:
As Giuliani fizzled and Thompson dropped out, McCain surged first, and Romney followed. Looks like it's going to be a two-man race between them. For now McCain has the advantage, but the Florida outcome is probably going to make all the difference.
In Rudy Giuliani's own home state, he is currently being trounced by McCain; in a new Gallup poll this week, McCain is 18-19 points ahead of him, at almost double his rating.
He does seem to have hit his floor now though, at about 20%, so perhaps that'll be where he'll end up on Feb 5 if he hasnt dropped out by then.
Romney is climbing in NY too, but only slowly and he's far behind.
Who benefits from high turnout?
Interesting detail in that last Gallup poll is that, perhaps intimidated by how far off the polls were in the last couple of primaries, it gives two sets of numbers for the NY and CA primaries (both Dems and Reps: one for a low turn-out election and one for a high-turnout election.
The differences are not large - 4 points more or less at most for any candidate. But it gives an indication of which candidates would benefit from an increased turnout. In California, a high turnout in the Dem primary would hurt Hillary; in NY, it wouldnt make much difference.
In the Republican primary in NY, a high turnout would benefit Giuliani and also McCain, and would hurt Romney and Huckabee. In California too, it would hurt Romney, but not Huckabee.