"Duel in the Sun" was my first thought, but I wasn't sure he felt lust for Jennifer Jones. However, he certainly had a glint in his eyes as he eyed her low cut blouse and advised her that it would be wise to dress more conservatively.

I almost put that movie down as my second choice for the preacher.
New question. (Oldie) This character actor was:
1. The Dutch Governor of New Amsterdam
2. A con artist on a cruise ship
3. A sadistic small town doctor/surgeon