Reply
Wed 21 Mar, 2007 02:36 pm
Published on Monday, March 19, 2007 by the Los Angeles Times
Why Aren't The Bush Daughters In Iraq?
The President's Family Has Set An Appallingly Bad Example For Wartime Sacrifice
by Kitty Kelley
When I was a little girl in a convent school, the nuns impressed on me the power of setting a good example. These beloved teachers are no longer around to instruct the president and his family, so I recommend that the Bushes learn from Mark Twain, who said: "Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest."
My suggestion comes after the White House announcement earlier this month that Jenna Bush, one of the president's twin daughters, is writing a book on her all-expenses-paid trip to Panama, where she worked for a few weeks as an intern for UNICEF. Jenna Bush is quoted as saying she will donate her earnings from her book to UNICEF, a commendable gesture, considering her father's net worth of $20 million. But while the 25-year-old makes the rounds of TV talk shows this fall in a White House limousine, dozens of her contemporaries will be arriving home from Iraq in wooden boxes. In Britain, Prince Harry is insisting on going off to Iraq ?- even as his country is reducing its troop commitment.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt showed how the power of good example could also be powerfully good politics. When he led the country to sacrifice in World War II, his children enlisted and his wife traveled to military bases to counsel and comfort the families of soldiers. Newsreels showed the president's four sons fighting with the Marines in the Pacific, flying with the Army Air Forces in North Africa and landing with the Navy at Normandy. Soon other public figures followed suit ?- movie stars (James Stewart and Clark Gable) enlisted and sports heroes (Joe DiMaggio and Hank Greenberg) went off to war.
The contrast between FDR's good example during wartime and that of George W. Bush is stark and sad. The Bush family rallies to the political campaigns of its scions and spends months on the road raising money and shaking hands to put their men into public office. In fact, the public image of their cohesive family ?- the pearl-choked matriarch surrounded by progeny and springer spaniels ?- helped cinch more than one presidency for the Bushes. Yet now, when its legacy is most in peril, the family seems to be squandering its good will on a mess of celebridreck.
The president tells us Iraq is a "noble" war, but his wife, his children and his nieces and nephews are not listening. None has enlisted in the armed services, and none seems to be paying attention to the sacrifices of military families. Until Jenna's trip to Panama, the presidential daughters performed community service only when mandated by a court after they were cited for underage drinking. Since then they have surfaced in public during lavish presidential trips with their parents, bar-hopping outings in Georgetown and champagne-popping art openings in New York.
The first lady, so often lauded for her love of literacy, has not been seen in the reading rooms of veterans' hospitals. The president's sister, Doro, publicly picketed Al Gore's last days in the vice president's mansion as he awaited the Supreme Court's decision on the Florida recount of 2000. Yet she has been strangely absent from publicly supporting her brother's war.
The presidential nieces and nephews also have missed the memo on setting a good public example. Ashley Bush ?- the youngest daughter of the president's brother, Neil, and Neil's ex-wife, Sharon ?- was presented to Manhattan society at the 52nd Annual International Debutantes Ball at the Waldorf Astoria. Her older sister, Lauren, a runway model, told London's Evening Standard that she is a student ambassador for the United Nations World Food Program, but she would not lobby her uncle for U.S. funds. Her cousin, Billy Bush, chronicles the lives of celebrities on "Access Hollywood."
"Uncle Bucky," as William H.T. Bush is known within the family, is one presidential relative who has profited from the Iraq war. He recently sold all of his shares in Engineered Support Systems Inc. (ESSI), a St. Louis-based company that has flourished under the president's no-bid policy for military contractors. Uncle Bucky told the Los Angeles Times that he would have preferred that ESSI, on whose board he sits, was not involved in Iraq, "but, unfortunately, we live in a troubled world."
The only member of the Bush family to show the strains of our "troubled world" is former President George H.W. Bush, who shed tears recently while addressing the Florida Legislature. The elder Bush was talking about son Jeb's gubernatorial loss in 1994. Jeb, who was later elected, tried to console him. But the sobs of Bush 41 seemed to be more about his older son's "noble" war.
Perhaps the father's sadness sprang from his own experience fighting in what his parents called "Mr. Roosevelt's war" ?- the good war ?- the war that saved the world from tyranny. He enlisted at 18 to fly torpedo bombers. He flew 58 missions in two years and returned home a war hero. Since then, no one in his large family has seen fit to follow his sterling example of service and patriotism.
© 2007 Los Angeles Times
What would they do there, besides drink and apply nail polish?
Re: President's family wartime sacrifice.
au1929 wrote:Franklin Delano Roosevelt showed how the power of good example could also be powerfully good politics. When he led the country to sacrifice in World War II, his children enlisted and his wife traveled to military bases to counsel and comfort the families of soldiers. Newsreels showed the president's four sons fighting with the Marines in the Pacific, flying with the Army Air Forces in North Africa and landing with the Navy at Normandy. Soon other public figures followed suit ?- movie stars (James Stewart and Clark Gable) enlisted and sports heroes (Joe DiMaggio and Hank Greenberg) went off to war.
Hmmm.. Here is a question that maybe Ms. Kelley could clear up. She says "
his children enlisted" and then mentions "
Newsreels showed the president's four sons...".
I'd like to know what unit FDR's daughter, Anna, served with. Was she in the Army, Navy or the Marine Corps?
Also, if James Roosevelt enlisted as a show of support as she states then why was it that he got commissioned in 1936 - 5 years before the war started? (I won't even ask how he got commissioned directly as a Lt. Col. without ever having served in any of the 4 lower officer ranks.)
Ms. Kelley is playing a little fast and lose with facts to make her point again.
Doh! Brian Williams just reported on tonight NBC Evening News that Bush's nephew begins OCS (Officer Candidate School) for the Navy tomorrow. Something about being an Intelligence Officer.
fishin wrote:Doh! Brian Williams just reported on tonight NBC Evening News that Bush's nephew begins OCS (Officer Candidate School) for the Navy tomorrow. Something about being an Intelligence Officer.
Bah, they don't see action! j/k
But anyone who passes OCS - man. that's a tough person
Cycloptichorn
Re: President's family wartime sacrifice.
fishin wrote:
Also, if James Roosevelt enlisted as a show of support as she states then why was it that he got commissioned in 1936 - 5 years before the war started? (I won't even ask how he got commissioned directly as a Lt. Col. without ever having served in any of the 4 lower officer ranks.)
Ms. Kelley is playing a little fast and lose with facts to make her point again.
Speaking of playing fast and loose.
Quote: ROOSEVELT, James, (son of President Franklin D. Roosevelt...
went on active duty as a captain in the United States Marine Corps in November 1940; promoted to colonel April 13, 1944, and served in the Pacific Theater; released from active duty in August 1945
http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/biodisplay.pl?index=R000426
Then there is this fairly comprehensive bio of his military service
http://hqinet001.hqmc.usmc.mil/HD/Historical/Whos_Who/Roosevelt_J.htm
George P. Bush, a nephew of President Bush who was a hit on the campaign trail, has been accepted in the Navy Reserve as an intelligence officer and has begun the process of being commissioned for eight years of service.
Bush, 30, said in a telephone interview from his office at a real estate development firm in Fort Worth, Texas, that he was moved to join the service in part when he attended the rainy commissioning in October of the aircraft carrier named for his grandfather -- the USS George H.W. Bush.
"My grandfather's my hero, and what really sold me on the ultimate decision was having the chance to see the CVN-77 be commissioned under his name," he said. "That was pretty moving, and I had a chance to meet some Navy admirals, as well. I had a chance to talk to them briefly about the opportunity, and I was won over."
George Prescott Bush, the oldest son of former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, said the death of Pat Tillman, the NFL player and Army Ranger who was killed in Afghanistan in 2004 in what was later determined to be a friendly-fire incident, "was a wake-up call for me." He said he even "looked into active duty" and had somber conversations with his wife about the possibility.
Bush said he had not intended to announce his plans. "Honestly, I'm kind of a little disappointed that the word got out," he said. "I was hoping to keep this as confidential as possible. I'm not doing it for political purposes or anything along those lines. I'm just doing it because I've been inspired by the friends of mine that have served, either through the JAG (military law) program or through the Reserves. I thought this was a small way that I could get involved."
Bush, who said he plans to "stay out of 2008," is a leader of the Maverick PAC, which was formed by young Texas donors to the Bush-Cheney campaign. The group has a series of meetings scheduled with the Republican presidential candidates.
Bush expects to receive his commission in a month or two. He will go to officer candidate school in Rhode Island, then intelligence school in Virginia Beach. The commitment involves two weeks of annual training. He can volunteer for active duty or be deployed after he finishes his intelligence certification, which takes about two years.
He'll have to run a mile and a half in 13 minutes, which he said he can do now, but he's trying to get down to the 10 minutes and 30 seconds required for SEALs and special operations. He's also a golfer and weightlifter.
Bush is chief operating officer and part owner of his firm, which provides equity capital to developers, most of whom are involved in specialty shopping centers with high-end tenants such as Starbucks.
Though he was raised in Florida, Bush settled in Texas after graduating from Rice University and the University of Texas Law School. He is a member of the board of directors of the Fort Worth Chamber of Commerce and the Fort Worth Hispanic Chamber of Commerce and is involved with the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center in Houston. Bush attends a small Catholic parish in downtown Fort Worth.
Bush was known as "George P." during his frequent travels on his uncle's plane during the 2000 campaign. He drew shrieks from the ladies and was compared to John F. Kennedy Jr. when he spoke at the Republican National Convention. During the 2004 campaign, he was a clerk for a federal judge; the Hatch Act prevented him from getting involved until the final months, when he had a heavy schedule of appearances in swing states with large Hispanic populations, including Florida, Colorado, Nevada and New Mexico.
Bush wouldn't talk about any political plans of his own, but friends say they believe the family may soon be in store for another gubernatorial campaign.
Re: President's family wartime sacrifice.
parados wrote:fishin wrote:
Also, if James Roosevelt enlisted as a show of support as she states then why was it that he got commissioned in 1936 - 5 years before the war started? (I won't even ask how he got commissioned directly as a Lt. Col. without ever having served in any of the 4 lower officer ranks.)
Ms. Kelley is playing a little fast and lose with facts to make her point again.
Speaking of playing fast and loose.
Quote: ROOSEVELT, James, (son of President Franklin D. Roosevelt...
went on active duty as a captain in the United States Marine Corps in November 1940; promoted to colonel April 13, 1944, and served in the Pacific Theater; released from active duty in August 1945
http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/biodisplay.pl?index=R000426
Then there is this fairly comprehensive bio of his military service
http://hqinet001.hqmc.usmc.mil/HD/Historical/Whos_Who/Roosevelt_J.htm
And why did you only C&P the part about him serving from 1940 on? Your own 2nd link says "
He entered the Marine Corps on 13 November 1936 as a lietuenant colonel in the Reserve, and completed various period of active duty - with the Marine Detachment aboard the USS Indianapolis; with Fleet Landing Exercise #4 (FLEX-4) in the San Juan-Culebra-Virgin Islands area on reconnaissance patrols and experiments with raiding and patrolling parties; and at Parris Island, South Carolina, in connection with testing of anti-aircraft batteries."
Yeah fishin, and why did you leave out this part?
Quote:On 3 October 1939, he requested and was granted permission to resign his commission as a lieutenant colonel. Shortly thereafter, at his own request, he was re-commissioned in the Marine Corps Reserve, in the grade of captain, on 24 November 1939.
parados wrote:Yeah fishin, and why did you leave out this part?
Quote:On 3 October 1939, he requested and was granted permission to resign his commission as a lieutenant colonel. Shortly thereafter, at his own request, he was re-commissioned in the Marine Corps Reserve, in the grade of captain, on 24 November 1939.
Because it is irrelevant?
Once he entered the service in 1936 he had an 8 year obligation. When he resigned his commision he went from Active Duty to Inactive Reserves. 7 weeks later he went from Inactive Reserves to Active Reserves.
The fact that he resigned his commission and then re-entered the active reserves in just under 2 months in 1939 doesn't change the fact that it was all still done well before the U.S. entered WWII in 1941 or even before the draft was started in Septemebr of 1940.
Cycloptichorn wrote:But anyone who passes OCS - man. that's a tough person
Cycloptichorn
What is so special with it?
Quote:He entered the Marine Corps on 13 November 1936 as a lietuenant colonel in the Reserve
I don't see where Kelly claimed they enlisted after Pearl Harbor. Your argument seems to be that they didn't enlist when you think they should have rather than arguing that they didn't serve.
Walter Hinteler wrote:Cycloptichorn wrote:But anyone who passes OCS - man. that's a tough person
Cycloptichorn
What is so special with it?
Had a frat brother who went one summer, he was a sniper in the marines before he came to college. Quiet guy, tough guy.
When he got back from OCS he said it was by far the most difficult challenge of his life, designed to strain him in every possible direction and matrix until he broke - which he said they all did, without a doubt, or they kept trying until you did - and then built up stronger.
The stories were just plain nuts. I have respect for anyone who passes.
Cycloptichorn
Must be different here: after I had passed it, I decided to keep my "normal-conscript-status" :wink:
parados wrote:Quote:He entered the Marine Corps on 13 November 1936 as a lietuenant colonel in the Reserve
I don't see where Kelly claimed they enlisted after Pearl Harbor. Your argument seems to be that they didn't enlist when you think they should have rather than arguing that they didn't serve.
I didn't dispute that his children (or at least 4 of them) served. In my original comment I quoted and directly responded to Kelley's statement:
Quote:Franklin Delano Roosevelt showed how the power of good example could also be powerfully good politics. When he led the country to sacrifice in World War II, his children enlisted and his wife traveled to military bases to counsel and comfort the families of soldiers.
She puts the enlistments as occuring after FDR "led the country to sacrifice in World War II". By starting the sentence with "When..." she is creating a timeline. The sequence of events didn't happen as she implies with that timeline, hence the term "fast and loose".
So, the proposed new criterion is that if a president uses the military, his relatives must enlist. Henceforth, any president who uses the military and whose family doesn't join up will be deemed a hypocrite. Maybe the president should just shoot a few relatives to show solidarity with those who have lost family members in the war, so as not to appear hypocritical.
Brandon9000 wrote:So, the proposed new criterion is that if a president uses the military, his relatives must enlist. Henceforth, any president who uses the military and whose family doesn't join up will be deemed a hypocrite. Maybe the president should just shoot a few relatives to show solidarity with those who have lost family members in the war, so as not to appear hypocritical.
How many places did Clinton send the military during his Admin? I don't recall any one complaining about his daughter not being in the military. My younger brother was in during the Clinton years and he was sent to Bosnia for about a year and then was home for 2 months before being sent to Haiti for another 6 months or so. No one said **** about the military being sent to these places and how long it was between deployments for soldiers. Bosnia and Haiti were worthless deployments and didn't serve the national interest of the US.
I could careless if a politician has family members in the military, it doesn't have any bearing on the politician but on the member who joined. You can't make someone join and you can't keep an able bodied person from joining. To make an issue of whether a politician has family in the military I think is lame. Who cares if they do or not.
fishin wrote: By starting the sentence with "When..." she is creating a timeline. The sequence of events didn't happen as she implies with that timeline, hence the term "fast and loose".
might be how different people/generations learn grammar. I read that as meaning when, when, when (not a timeline) - so three discrete events.
<grammar nerd interest only>
Yes, in fact, back in 1996 I swear Chelsea handed me a flyer as I walked down Michigan Avenue in Chicago. Why wasn't she in Kuwait guarding the no-fly zone?
KITTY KELLY QUOTE:
Quote:When I was a little girl in a convent school, the nuns impressed on me...
MS Kelly:
The nuns "impressed" so many kids, that when these kids finally reached adulthood they left the Catholic
Church and finally were able to enjoy life .