1
   

Napoleon was not given arsenic

 
 
Reply Wed 17 Jan, 2007 09:52 am
Putting to rest a 200-year-old mystery, scientists say Napoleon Bonaparte died from an advanced case of gastric cancer and not arsenic poisoning as some had speculated.

After being defeated by the British in 1815, the French Emperor was exiled to St. Helena--an island in the South Atlantic Ocean. Six years later, at the age of 52, Bonaparte whispered his last words, "Head of Army!"

An autopsy at the time determined that stomach cancer was the cause of his death. But some arsenic found in 1961 in the ruler's hair sparked rumors of poisoning. Had Napoleon escaped exile, he could have changed the balance of power in Europe; therefore murder speculations didn't seem outlandish.

However, a new study--combining current medical knowledge, autopsy reports, Bonaparte's physician memoirs, eyewitness accounts, and family medical histories--found that gastrointestinal bleeding was the immediate cause of death.

"This analysis suggests that, even if the emperor had been released or escaped from the island, his terminal condition would have prevented him from playing a further major role in the theater of European history," said lead study author, Robert Genta of University of Texas Southwestern. "Even today, with the availability of sophisticated surgical techniques and chemotherapies, patients with gastric cancer as advanced as Napoleon's have a poor prognosis."

A four-inch lesion

The original autopsy descriptions indicated that Bonaparte's stomach had two ulcerated lesions: a large one on the stomach and a smaller one that had pierced through the stomach wall and reached the liver.

Genta and his colleagues compared the description of these lesions with current images of 50 benign ulcers and 50 gastric cancers and found that the emperor's lesions were cancerous.

"It was a huge mass from the entrance of his stomach to the exit. It was at least 10 centimeters [4 inches] long." Genta said. "Size alone suggests the lesion was cancer."

A severe case

Bonaparte, the researchers said, had a very severe case of the cancer which had spread to other organs.

"Even if treated today, he'd have been dead within a year," Genta said.

Although the emperor's father also died from stomach cancer, Bonaparte's cancer most likely stemmed from an ulcer-causing bacterial infection, the researchers said.�

A diet full of salt-preserved foods but sparse in fruits and vegetables--common fare for long military campaigns--increased Napoleon's risk for gastric cancer, Genta said.


Taken from here...
  • Topic Stats
  • Top Replies
  • Link to this Topic
Type: Discussion • Score: 1 • Views: 1,089 • Replies: 7
No top replies

 
Merry Andrew
 
  1  
Reply Wed 17 Jan, 2007 10:09 pm
Some historians have long advanced the speculation that the reason we see him with one hand stuck inside in his waistcoat (the classic 'Napoleonic pose') in so many portraits was not due to any kind of posturing as some have opined. Rather, he was gently massaging a very painful tummy.
0 Replies
 
Walter Hinteler
 
  1  
Reply Thu 18 Jan, 2007 12:11 am
The study is online here

Quote:
Summary
Background
Numerous hypotheses on the cause of Napoleon Bonaparte's death have been proposed, including hereditary gastric cancer, arsenic poisoning, and inappropriate medical treatment. We aimed to determine the etiology and pathogenesis of Napoleon's illness by a comparison of historical information with current clinicopathologic knowledge.

Investigations
Evaluation of Napoleon's clinical history, original autopsy reports, and of historical documents. The clinicopathologic data from 135 gastric cancer patients were used for comparison with the data available on Napoleon.

Diagnosis
At least T3N1M0 (stage IIIA) gastric cancer. Napoleon's tumor extended from the cardia to the pylorus (>10 cm) without infiltration of adjacent structures, which provides strong evidence for at least stage T3. The N1 stage was determined by the presence of several enlarged and hardened regional (perigastric) lymph nodes, and the M0 stage by the absence of distant metastasis. Analysis of the available historical documents indicates that Napoleon's main risk factor might have been Helicobacter pylori infection rather than a familial predisposition.

Conclusions
Our analysis suggests that Napoleon's illness was a sporadic gastric carcinoma of advanced stage. Patients with such tumors have a notoriously poor prognosis.


source: see above
0 Replies
 
cello
 
  1  
Reply Thu 18 Jan, 2007 08:58 pm
What a coincidence! I just saw a 4-DVD about his life (quite excellent) and it was really sad to see him being prisoner on a tiny island at the end. He was in constant pain and thought that he was being slowly poisoned. I can't imagine how he must have suffered without any treatment.
0 Replies
 
syntinen
 
  1  
Reply Mon 29 Jan, 2007 01:58 pm
Quote:
Some historians have long advanced the speculation that the reason we see him with one hand stuck inside in his waistcoat (the classic 'Napoleonic pose') in so many portraits was not due to any kind of posturing as some have opined. Rather, he was gently massaging a very painful tummy.

If so, they can't have seen many 18th-century paintings, because this was one of the stock poses in which gentlemen had their portraits painted!

It may not have been the cause of Napoleon's death,but the arsenic in his hair may not have been the reuslt of deliberate poisoning at al. A piece of the wallpaper from his room at Longwood survives in an East Anglian museum, and it is an arsenic-based green. The damp of Longwood (which everybody who stayed there complained of) would have caused the arsenic to dissolve out into the air of the room.
0 Replies
 
Walter Hinteler
 
  1  
Reply Mon 29 Jan, 2007 02:06 pm
Scheele's green and Emerald green are and were known to be a highly arsenic colour.

The arsenic in the wallpapers of Napoleon's rooms at St. Helena wasn't high enough.

See:
Ben Weider & Sten Forshufvud, Assassination on St Helena Revisited, John Wiley & Sons, 1995,
Jones, DEH, Ledingham, KWL "Arsenic in Napoleon's Wallpaper" Nature, Vol. 299 Oct. 14, 1982 p. 626-7,
New Scientist, 14 October 1982, pp. 101-104.
0 Replies
 
Merry Andrew
 
  1  
Reply Mon 29 Jan, 2007 03:27 pm
syntinen wrote:
Quote:
Some historians have long advanced the speculation that the reason we see him with one hand stuck inside in his waistcoat (the classic 'Napoleonic pose') in so many portraits was not due to any kind of posturing as some have opined. Rather, he was gently massaging a very painful tummy.

If so, they can't have seen many 18th-century paintings, because this was one of the stock poses in which gentlemen had their portraits painted!

It may not have been the cause of Napoleon's death,but the arsenic in his hair may not have been the reuslt of deliberate poisoning at al. A piece of the wallpaper from his room at Longwood survives in an East Anglian museum, and it is an arsenic-based green. The damp of Longwood (which everybody who stayed there complained of) would have caused the arsenic to dissolve out into the air of the room.


Yes, but it became fashionable, in part, because Bonaparte popularized it.
0 Replies
 
hamburger
 
  1  
Reply Mon 29 Jan, 2007 04:07 pm
Quote:
Some historians have long advanced the speculation that the reason we see him with one hand stuck inside in his waistcoat (the classic 'Napoleonic pose') in so many portraits was not due to any kind of posturing as some have opined. Rather, he was gently massaging a very painful tummy.


i have been told more than once by g.i. specialists that gently massaging the tummy is a good way to calm a 'nervous' stomach - and it works !
20 to 30 minutes of gentle stomach massage does wonders for a wonky tummy .
hbg
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

HAPPY ANNIVERSARY, EVERYONE! - Discussion by OmSigDAVID
WIND AND WATER - Discussion by Setanta
Who ordered the construction of the Berlin Wall? - Discussion by Walter Hinteler
True version of Vlad Dracula, 15'th century - Discussion by gungasnake
ONE SMALL STEP . . . - Discussion by Setanta
History of Gun Control - Discussion by gungasnake
Where did our notion of a 'scholar' come from? - Discussion by TuringEquivalent
 
  1. Forums
  2. » Napoleon was not given arsenic
Copyright © 2024 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.04 seconds on 05/03/2024 at 10:23:32