Reply
Wed 6 Dec, 2006 04:19 pm
I wrote a paper in my English class and when I got it back for revision (it was edited by fellow students) they told me to use "maybe another, more literate term" instead of 'asinine'.
This was the sentence: "For those of us with an asinine amount of music...."
I was under the imperssion that asinine meant something along the lines of 'ridiculous.'
And when I asked my professor, she said "Are you sure you spelled it right?" "Maybe use something like 'wicked' instead."
Am I wrong here!?
Main Entry: as·i·nine
Pronunciation: 'a-s&-"nIn
Function: adjective
Etymology: Latin asininus, from asinus ass
1 : extremely or utterly foolish <an>
2 : of, relating to, or resembling an ass
I supose you could use that word, although it doesn't seem to fit really IMO. But if you meant a "ridiculous amount of music" according to M-W, technically you're right.
What other word should I use instead then?
Wrong word for that sentence.
mycdplayerisbroke wrote:What other word should I use instead then?
How about ridiculous? or "for those of us with a vast music collection...." or something like that.
Asinine has a negative conotation. Like, "That is the most asinine thing you've ever said..."
No, wrong word to use in a submission to that asinine teacher. The word is perfectly fine in context as employed, the teacherr's attritude - and perhaps the teacher's erudition - could stand broadening.
I believe it was the students who made that verdict, timber.
Now, if I'd written that sentence, it prolly wouldagone something like " ... for those of us with an absolutely asinine amount of downloaded digital ditties ... "
To my mind "asinine" is once-trendy bit of slang usually modifying a person or an action.
I'm not sure that any amount of music can be compared to a beast of burden.
"Asinine amount of music" doesn't automatically advance my notion of how much music you have in or out of that sentence.
I believe your intention is to poke fun at yourself, but by dragging your acquisitive nature, hooves first, into the discussion you weaken the thrust of your narrative.
Consider: "A jack-assy amount of music". A hooved animal of any derivation doesn't fly.
Then there was the person whose sister was attacked by insects. To save money on the telegraph, she wrote her parents; "Adamant bitter asinine places."
Sorry for the digression.
There is a word that conveys the idea of an absurd amount as well as having the word ass in it.
Assload.
I don't think mycdplayerisbroke's use of the word 'asinine' is wrong... but then I'm famous to myself and others for playing with words from time to time.
I don't say "wrong". I say "ungraceful".