@JTT,
JTT wrote:
Without the billions in aid that they've received over the years, the country Israel, would be already forgotten.
That might be correct; however, a non-sequitor, since you forgot to say to whom it would be forgotten. The answer is: forgotten by the Gentile masses. The Gentile masses have no reason to remember Israel.
I believe many people are talking at cross-purposes when taking one or the other side of U.S. Israeli policy. Jews, I believe as a group, do not subscribe to the paradigm of those with the greatest number should have the ethical right to be the dominant group making decisions. That I believe is a Gentile paradigm. So, since there are more Gentiles in the U.S., and more Gentiles having died in U.S. wars, many Gentiles may believe they have earned the right (through sheer numbers and the greater "blood equity" they have earned through dying in U.S. wars - aka making them "more American") to have their opinions reflect the direction of U.S. foreign policy. However, I believe Jews, as a group, relate to "time" as the rationale as to who should ethically be dominant in decision making. In "time" I include who first discovered that there might be only one God, rather than a pantheon of pagan Gods, and also how long American Jews have lived in this country (oftentimes far longer than the families of many critics of U.S. Israeli policy). I will admit that while Jews do not have the same number of "dead" from the many U.S. wars, they have helped the U.S. domestic economy far out of proportion to their small numbers. So, which criterion may be better for the U.S.? The answer is based on who is asked. The answer is subjective and might correlate to one's social-economic class/religion/ethnicity.
Mind you, I do not believe there were as many vocal critics of WASP's who were pro-Lend Lease, prior to WWII. And, we do know that WASP's reflect a blood connection to Britain. Odd that people are so concerned about Jewish Americans and their concern for Israel, while concerns were not so anti-WASP during Lend Lease and the ensuing WWII (the U.S. lost 500,000 military, fighting in behalf of other nations in WWII; the U.S. never lost one military life, fighting in behalf of Israel's four wars in the 20th century). So, who is not seeing the forest for the trees?