Reply
Wed 7 Jun, 2006 09:31 am
Senate to consider letting Hawaiians pursue sovereignty
By Brian DeBose
THE WASHINGTON TIMES
Published June 7, 2006
Hawaii Sen. Daniel K. Akaka thinks Hawaiians should be allowed to govern themselves as Native Americans and Alaskans do, and after seven years of pushing a bill to start the process, the Senate is expected to take it up this week.
Mr. Akaka says the bill is a way to give "indigenous" Hawaiians a sense of pride and a chance for sovereignty for the first time since 1893, when Queen Liliuokalani was deposed and lands were illegally seized by U.S. Marines and a cadre of sugar-plantation businessmen.
"For the first time, if it passes, Hawaiians will have parity and be able to form a government entity to address their concerns, since the overthrow," Mr. Akaka said.
Republican senators annually have blocked the legislation, saying it would violate the Constitution by establishing a sovereign race-based government. It is only coming up now through a deal worked out between Democratic and Republican leaders to move other bills.
Opponents, including many native Hawaiians, say the bill opens up a "Pandora's box" of new race classifications and called the bill ambiguous as to what benefits it will bring.
The bill calls for an Office of Native Hawaiian Relations in the Department of the Interior, and a Native Hawaiian Interagency Coordinating Group to administer programs, a commission that would certify who are indigenous Hawaiians, and provides a process of reorganization of the Native Hawaiian governing entity.
"The bill will not authorize gaming in Hawaii. The bill will not allow private lands to be taken. The bill will not create a reservation in Hawaii," Mr. Akaka said.
The legislation is supported by both Republican and Democratic senators, primarily those from states with substantial Native American and Eskimo populations, as well as the American Bar Association and Alaska Federation of Natives.
Sen. Jon Kyl, Arizona Republican, who has kept the bill from coming to the floor, said the creation of a native Hawaiian government -- composed only of redefined natives and whose members can only be voted in by native Hawaiians -- could divide Hawaii's people.
"Unlike reservation Indians, Native Hawaiians do not live in one area of the State that is set aside for Indians; they live in the same cities and neighborhoods and on the same streets, as other Hawaiians do," Mr. Kyl said.
Reservation Indian tribes have the power to tax, regulate and make laws for members. There are an estimated 400,000 Native Hawaiians living throughout the United States.
Native Hawaiians also say it "too narrowly" redefines who is indigenous.
"It is only for people of Native Hawaiian blood," said 'Ehu Kekahu Cardwell, director of the Koani Foundation, a grass-roots group dedicated to restoring the Hawaiian nation.
"We want it to be for any descendants of kingdom nationals who were loyal to the queen during the time she was deposed. We want everyone to be able to have a say in how this turns out," Mr. Cardwell said.
Leon Siu, a Chinese Hawaiian lobbying against the bill on Capitol Hill, said it has already caused division in Hawaii.
"We reject a race issue being brought into our community; the bill will change the definition of who we are," he said. "Native Hawaiian is not a pure bloodline and ... this bill will introduce a new concept of racial apartheid."
Mr. Siu's father fled China in search of a better life and settled in Hawaii 70 years ago, as did hundreds of thousands of foreign nationals from America, Japan, China, Vietnam, and the Philippines who became Hawaiian citizens.
The Hawaiian monarchy historically never kept anyone from participating in its government structure and did not have a race-specific citizenship definition.
One of the most salient points in the debate will be a history lesson on how Hawaii became a U.S. territory and a state, which Native Hawaiians say was an "illegal annexation."
Queen Liliuokalani, the last Hawaiian monarch, was deposed in 1893 by a collection of sugar exporters doing business on the island with the complicity of the U.S. government.
Hawaii became a U.S. territory under a congressional resolution passed in the late 1890s, but the Constitution states that the U.S. can only acquire land held by sovereign foreign nations through a formal treaty.
The treaty authorized by the Safety Commission -- an illegitimate government established by the sugar plantation owners -- failed in Congress after 38,000 of the 40,000 natives living on the island in 1897 petitioned the Congress to reject it.
Congress formally acknowledged that the coup was unlawful in an apology resolution in 1993.
"This is just the next step in that process of acknowledging the wrong committed against the Native Hawaiian people and recognize them as a sovereign entity," said Donalyn Dela Cruz, spokeswoman for Mr. Akaka.
Good for Akaka and I wish the kama'aina well. But I wonder what the actual chances of passage of this bill are. It's been discussed at length in the past. The haoles who run the state don't really want the kama'aina to get too independent.
Hawaii Declaration re Hawaii Ecumenical Coalition on Tourism
The 1989
Hawaii Declaration of the Hawai'i Ecumenical Coalition on Tourism Conference
TOURISM IN HAWAII: Its Impact on Native Hawaiians And Its Challenge to the Churches
The Hawai'i Ecumenical Coalition on Tourism convened an historic conference on "Tourism in Hawai'i: Its Impact on Native Hawaiians and Its Challenge to the Churches." Over 75 people participated in the conference from August 25-28, 1989 at St. Stephen's Diocesan Center on O'ahu. Nearly half of these were Native Hawaiians from Kaua'i, O'ahu, Moloka'i, Lana'i, Maui and Hawai'i, who represented their church, religious and native organizations. Other representatives of church and religious groups in Hawai'i as well as national and international visitors constituted the rest. For the purpose of this conference, Native Hawaiians were identified as those who trace their ancestry prior to 1778 A.D. in Hawai'i.
The conference was initiated and organized by the Hawai'i Ecumenical Coalition Tourism, the Hawai'i Council of Churches, American Friends Service Committee, and the Hawaii Conference of the United Church of Christ in collaboration with the Ecumenical Coalition for Third World Tourism (ECTWT) and the North American Coordinating Center for Responsible Tourism (CRT). The fourteen international participants include representatives from ECTWT, CRT, the Third World Tourism Ecumenical European Net, the World Council of Churches (Program to Combat Racism), the National Council of Churches of Christ in the U.S.A., the Republic of the Marshall Islands, the Republic of Belau, the Republic of Fiji, Japan, the Confederated Tribes of the Warm Springs Reservation of Oregon, and the Haida Nation of North America.
A program of exposure and fieldtrips to see the realities of tourism in Hawai'i was organized for the international participants. At the conference itself, participants heard competent research on tourism in Hawai'i, agonizing testimonies from many Native Hawaiians who have been victimized by tourism as well as stories of successful native efforts in self-sufficiency and self-determination. The participants divided into seven groups whose discussions were reported back for plenary. Subsequent analysis and careful deliberation led us to the following conclusions:
Contrary to the claims of its promoters, tourism, the biggest industry in Hawai'i, has not benefited the poor and the oppressed Native Hawaiian people. Tourism is not an indigenous practice; nor has it been initiated by the Native Hawaiian people. Rather, tourism promotion and development has been directed and controlled by those who already control wealth and power, nationally and internationally. Its primary purpose is to make money.
As such, tourism is a new form of exploitation. As a consequence, the Native Hawaiian people suffer the most; their culture has been increasingly threatened, their beaches and even their sacred sites have been taken over or intruded upon in order to build tourist resorts and related developments.
Furthermore, tourism brings and expands the evil of an economy which perpetuates the poverty of Native Hawaiian people and which leads to sexual and domestic violence and substance abuse among the Native Hawaiian people. In addition, sexism and racism are closely interlinked with tourism. In short, tourism, as it exists today, is detrimental to the life, well-being and spiritual health of native Hawaiian people. If not checked and transformed, it will bring grave harm, not only to the Native Hawaiian people, but also to all people living in Hawai'i.
The plight of Native Hawaiian people is but one example of the destructive impact that tourism is having on indigenous people in communities around the world. All is not well in "paradise." Indeed,
A STATE OF EMERGENCY EXISTS IN REGARD TO THE SURVIVAL, THE WELL-BEING, AND THE STATUS OF THE NATIVE HAWAIIAN PEOPLE ON THE ONE HAND AND THE NEAR EXTINCTION OF THE PRECIOUS AND FRAGIL NATURAL ENVIRONMENT OF THE OTHER.
CALL TO THE CHURCHES
The churches have a moral obligation and responsibility to raise awareness in its congregations and in the State of Hawai'i about tourism's negative impacts and consequences on native Hawaiians. The churches are called upon to "wrestle against the principalities and powers" which exploit people.
Furthermore, the churches must examine their history of involvement in Hawai'i's past, and recognize their role in the loss of Native Hawaiian control over their land and destiny and in the overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy. Such a recognition should lead to concrete actions on the part of the churches to rectify the wrongs which have been done.
Given these harsh and continuing realities, we, the participants of the conference, call upon the churches and religious institutions of Hawai'i, in consultation with Native Hawaiians, to initiate a process of reconciliation and reparations, as follows:
Acknowledge the anger expressed by Native Hawaiian people for the past actions of the missionaries, their descendants, and the churches and institutions they established;
Recognize that this anger is an expression of the suffering of the Native Hawaiian people; and
Publicly apologize to the Native Hawaiians within their own congregations and the larger Native Hawaiian community for the churches' involvement and participation in the destruction and erosion of Hawaiian culture, religious practices, land base, and the overthrow of Queen Lili'uokalani and the Hawaiian Monarchy.
I. Priority Rectifying Actions
We call upon the churches and religious institutions of Hawai'i to redress these injustices by advocating the following:
A. The return of public and private trust lands to the control of the Native Hawaiian people;
An immediate ban on all resort and related developments in those areas designated as sanctuaries by Native
B. Hawaiians, and in rural Hawaiian communities such as, Leeward and Windward Kaua'i, Leeward and Winward O'ahu, Moloka'i, Lana'i, East Maui and the districts of North Kohala, South Kona, and Ka'u on Hawai'i; and
C. Technical, financial and other support from the State of Hawai'i to Native Hawaiian projects which encourage economic self-sufficiency.
Furthermore, we call upon the churches and religious institutions of Hawai'i to support the political claims of Native Hawaiians to establish a sovereign entity, separate from the existing State and Federal governments, in order that they may achieve self-determination.
II. PUBLIC WITNESS
We call upon the churches and religious institutions of Hawai'i to take a stand for social justice and engage in political actions, as follows:
A. Make public an inventory of the holdings and use of all churches lands;
B. Return those church lands which justly belong to the Native Hawaiian people;
C. Reexamine the church lands and divest church funds currently being used for tourism purposes which negatively impact Native Hawaiians;
D. Refuse to participate in the public blessing of those projects which adversely impact Native Hawaiians or the environment;
E. Support worker demands for higher wages, a full time work week with benefits, and better working conditions in the tourist industry;
F. Hold the tourist industry and government accountable for the social problems associated with tourism: increased crime, racism, sexual and domestic violence and disruption, substance abuse, housing costs, and land taxes; and
G. Support policies to reverse current trends of tourist industry growth. The human and natural resources cannot withstand the near doubling of total annual tourists to Hawai'i from its current 6.5 to 11 million over the next two decades, projected by the Hawai'i Visitor's Bureau.
III. EDUCATION
We call upon the churches and religious institutions of Hawai'i to utilize and distribute educational materials and programs for both clergy and congregations in order to reevaluate misconceptions and dependency on tourism. These materials should:
A. Focus on Native Hawaiian culture;
B. Detail the negative effects of tourism on Native Hawaiian land and water rights, economy, and social life-style;
C. Promote native Hawaiian self-sufficiency, sanctuaries, and sovereignty; and
D. Present a truthful view of Hawaiian history including the involvement of the church and the U.S. government in the loss of Native Hawaiian land and power, and the overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy.
IV. RELIGIOUS UNDERSTANDING AND PRACTICE
We call upon the churches and religious institutions of Hawai'i to be reminded that in God's house are "many mansions," and that "The earth is the Lord's and the fullness thereof."
We call upon the churches and religious institutions of Hawai'i to acknowledge and respect Native Hawaiian rights to:
A. Practice and participate in traditional ceremonies and rituals with the same protection offered all religions;
B. Determine access to and protection of sacred sites and burial grounds, and public lands for ceremonial purposes; and
C. Utilize and access religious symbols for traditional ceremonies and rituals.
We further call upon the churches to live in harmony with God's creation of land, water, and air; and to integrate the Native Hawaiian culture into their religious services. Finally we call upon the churches to work towards the reestablishment of one day each week for rest and sanctuary in order to strengthen family relations.
V. CONTRIBUTIONS
We call upon the churches and religious institutions of Hawai'i to:
A. Provide spiritual support and a nurturing environment to the Native Hawaiian people;
B. Provide monetary support, expertise, use of facilities, land, and building sites for Hawaiian people;
C. Provide congregational support at Native Hawaiian public demonstrations;
D. Designate one service and offering each year to address the adverse effects of tourism on Native Hawaiian people; and
E. Recognize and support by staffing and funding, the Hawai'i Ecumenical Coalition on Tourism.
VI. CALL TO THE GLOBAL COMMUNITY
We call upon the global religious community to take actions as follows:
A. Recognize the negative impacts and consequences of tourism on Native Hawaiians and other indigenous people of the world;
B. Support the actions of the churches and religious groups of Hawai'i in consultation with Native Hawaiians to initiate a process of reconciliation and reparations;
C. Contribute funds and support and the Hawai'i Ecumenical Coalition on Tourism to act upon the 1989 Hawai'i Declaration;
D. Together with the Hawaii Ecumenical Coalition on Tourism, invite the Ecumenical Coalition on Third World Tourism to consider holding the "People's Forum on Tourism" in Hawai'i in 1993; and
E. Work with their own governments and businesses to stop further investments in the tourist industry in Hawai'i which have negative impacts and consequences on Native Hawaiians.
TOURISM IN HAWAI'I:
Its Impact on Native Hawaiians And Its Challenge to the Churches
INITIATING SPONSORS
Ecumenical Coalition for Third World Tourism
Center for Responsible Tourism
Hawai'i Council of Churches,
American Friends Service Committee
Hawaii Conference of the United Church of Christ
CONTRIBUTORS
World Council of Churches (Program to Combat Racism)
National Council of Churches of Christ in the U.S.A.
Catholic Diocese of Honolulu
St. Andrew's Cathedral
Buddhist Study Center
Church of the Crossroads
United Methodist Church, Hawai'i District
Harris United Methodist Church
Christian Church (Disciples of Christ), Pacific-Southwest Region
Abelard Foundation
Zentrum für Entwicklungsbezogene Bildung
Evangelische Missionswerk
Pohaku Fund, the Tides Foundation
BBB
The first time I visited Hawaii in the 1970s, I visited the Presbyterian Church's Polynesian Cultural Center. I was so angry at the missionary effort to destroy the Hawaiian culture and relegate it into a tourist show for money. How revolting! It was a beautifully executed show and the actors were talented, but to me, it made the Hawaiians look like circus freaks.
http://polynesia.com/?referrer=Google
BBB