blatham wrote:Actually, there's rather a lot of good discussion available on Krugman's recent columns and on Rich's recent columns (Matt Yglesias, Greg Sargeant at TPM and more). Sunstein seems to be unaware of these. And he certainly looks like he hasn't read either of Krugman's last two books, particularly the most recent.
1) It certainly looks like that. If he had read the books, he would have known that Krugman doesn't
like partisanship. He just thinks it inevitable. In a country that's split 50:50 between creationists and at least qualified acceptance of evolution, teaching evolution as the sound science that it is is inevitably a very partisan thing to do. It also happens to be the right thing to do. Likewise, in a two party system in which one party vehemently opposes universal heathcare in ignorance of clear evidence that it works, introducing any universal healthcare is inevitably a very partisan thing to do. Krugman and Obama both think it's the right thing to do. So, given that the right thing to do is partisan, Krugman's point is that Obama's desire for bipartisanship will get in the way of getting it done. Krugman writes plain English; the only way to miss his message is to read him second-hand through summaries by people who don't like him.
2) Since you mention Rich's recent columns, which were highly critical of Clinton and at least as numerous as Krugmans -- I don't remember anyone accusing rich of running a personal campaign against Hillary Clinton. The same goes for Maureen Dowd. Therefore, if Krugman's columns grate so much, it seems much more likely that the median Obama supporter is just more hostile to opposition than the median Clinton supporters.
For what it's worth, my own experience confirms this: For several months now, Obama was my second most favorite Democratic candidate, my number one being John Edwards. Now that Edwards is out of the race, Obama has moved up to #1, albeit by a fairly narrow margin. I think both Obama and Clinton would be good presidents, and my preference for Obama is only modest. Given these preferences, I would expect my views to attract about equal amounts of opposition. But that's not the case. I didn't keep notes about it, but I'm definitely getting more heat from Obama supporters. Not complaining, just comparing.