However, the Comments section to that item had me scratching my head about whether the "madrassa" line of attack might not go further than we in our sane minds would expect.
After all, the intellectual mix of liberal and neocon that is The New Republic is hardly a hotbed of conservative rabblerousing, yet even there the comments are
somewhat mixed, with a larger minority of posters than I expected reacting along the lines of "it's a legitimate concern". (And yes, I'm quoting selectively to point out the part that worries me):
Quote:I don't get it.
Obama went to a Moslem school. That's a fact.
The Republicans say that Obama went to a Moslem school, and let the public draw their own negative conclusions.
How is that a smear?
Quote:It's not just the Indonesian Muslim connection. Obama's paternal grandfather converted to Islam (he didn't like Christianity's 'turn the other cheek' philosophy, according to Obama's memoir). His father is portrayed as a non-religious man, but was given a Muslim burial. So Obama has a Muslim as well as a Christian heritage. Given current US realities, this will be an issue and how he handles it will be a test of his considerable political abilities. [..]
Quote:Obama's childhood orientation and indoctrination is a legitimate area of inquiry. [..]
If the man spent a portion of his youth in Indonesian schools, if he feels close kinship to his Kenyan roots, we have a right to know what that means in terms of his worldview.
He could even leverage it to his advantage as to his insight and understanding of world issues.
But, let's be real, if someone were running for president in 1940, or 1944, and had close family ties to Germany or Japan, it would probably have been an issue. If someone running for president in 1960 had spent part of his childhood in the Soviet Union, it would be an issue. [..]
Quote:I hear they worship an awesome God in the madrassahs.
Quote:[..] swifboating involved a set of buddies and participants who repudiated claims of heroism. there is no swiftboating with the muslim schooling here. this term is so overused and will backfire at some point. [..]
Quote:[..] voters [..] like their presidents' religions bland. Nice, gentlemanly, country club Protestantism. The kind you bring out on Sunday and holidays, if you bring it out at all.
Any religion that has the odor of fervor-- Evangelical, Baptist, Mormon, Roman Catholic, and, yes, Muslim makes people nervous.
Jimmy Carter was mocked for his devout Baptist beliefs. George W. Bush is accused of being a religious zealot. Jack Kennedy's Catholicism was a potential issue, as had been Al Smith's, partly because of supposed fealty to an outside authority, the Pope.
So [..] this is nothing new in American politics. It's not reserved for Muslims.
With the last post oddly ignoring that Obama isnt, actually, you know, Muslim.