@cicerone imposter,
cicerone imposter wrote:
How can you claim such an asinine idea when GW Bush did nothing about illegals for eight years, and the numbers of illegal continued to increase?
Agreed to a point. Reasons? The reasons as I see them is that Republicans have been demonized as not sympathetic to immigrants, wrongly of course, but combined with Bush's soft spot for Hispanics in the first place, he bent over backwards trying to placate the cry for compassion for the downtrodden, blah blah, blah. Bush invented the term, "compassionate conservatism," and ran on this concept, which really is nothing more than justifying and turning a blind eye to the millions of illegals coming to this country. Also, the Republican business owners liked this policy, for the reason that it gave them cheap, hard working laborers to do their work, provide their services, etc. Also, I think there was a dirty little secret belief that all the illegals were helping our economy.
Also, you have the Democrat Party and their allies encouraging policies of going soft on illegals, creating safe haven cities, turning a blind eye, underfunding efforts to arrest and send people back, accusing Republicans of racism, and actively signing up as many illegals and immigrants as voters. After all, the Hispanics form a huge constituency of theirs in border states, such as California, Arizona, New Mexico, and Texas, as well as other states as well, no denying of this.
The problem has gotten so bad that the numbers are questionable in terms of reversing this trend of ignoring the law. It had reached the point of politicians throwing up their hands and saying nothing could be done, sending people back was impractical, so various proposals of amnesty proliferated. McCain a good example of all of this.
Interestingly, now with the recession, and with some enforcement of employers illegal hiring practices, just like magic, many illegals have returned to Mexico, and the flow into this country has slowed, confirming that the politicians were wrong, that enforcement does work, and that sending people back was unnecessary, all you have to do is enforce the law and they will go back on their own, at least many of them.
All the people ever wanted in the first place was enforcement, and the problem melts away. It could have been done a long time ago. It remains in question whether the country has the resolve to enforce its own laws. Then all we need is a healthy, fair, and robust program of screening and bringing in legal immigrants, virtually everyone desires this, and if we did that, we could all get along, nobody is flying under the radar, everybody is a full participating citizen, and everyone gets respect.
Bottom line though, it has been clearly liberal policy that has perpetrated the illegal problem on this country, predominantly by Democrats, but also practiced by Republicans from time to time.