@okie,
Well, okie, here's how I see it: the United States have a very long track record of treating waterboarding as torture. That includes courts-martial of American soldiers who used that technique during the Spanish-American War, it includes the prosecutions of Japanese who waterboarded American soldiers by the Tokyo War Crimes Tribunal, and it includes Ronald Reagan’s Justice Department prosecuting a sheriff and some deputies for waterboarding prisoners.
The Bush administration instituted a secret program using
exactly the same technique that American courts, for over a hundred years, have treated as torture.
This seems as clear-cut as it can get.
I simply don't see how trying to justify a secret torture program, run by the United States of America, does not constitute "equivocating, justifying, and spinning, till the cows come home."