Re: China's policy of one child
zhy5735053 wrote:Chai Tea wrote:Unfortunatly, we can't spread people around the world so each person get 10 arcres. In addition, what is the condition of the 10 acres you would get?
Not all land is farmable (if that's a word) and now your talking about distribution. Would all the people live on the hard bits and middle of the desert, and have food shipped to them.
Some areas of the world are overpopulated, and some underpopulated.
Take Italy for example. Without looking up specific figures right now, their population is way down, and most grow is through emmigration.
On the other had, take some area of Africa, Inda, Mexico, etc.
Now China, with its "one child policy"....human rights violation at its finest. Promoting infantcide and forced abortions. I once watched a documentary about Chinas "death rooms" it will haunt me until the day I die. A baby is left in a room, and checked on once in a while to see if she is dead yet (almost always female).
The documentors found one of these children, still alive, too late to save. A baby that looked up with begging dry eyes that didn't look much human, until she opened her mouth and a weak croaked babys cry came out. Then and now I cannot control my emotions. I'll never be able to erase that from my mind. And it's happening right now, this very second.
That is what the one child policy results in
So, in answer to the question, over/under.....depends.
I just want to express my own opinions without any aggressive meaning.
I don't know which documentary have you read before, but, by the way, you can tell me the name of the documentary. Of course, China is facing some domestic problems, such as overpopulation, the policy was made according to China's own situation, I'm sure that most of Chinese can understand the policy, it's really a problem with a larger population as time goes by. What the world will be if there are too many people around you, even no more room for you to turn. It is terrible. and there are still many reasons for China too make the policy. You, esp. some bad mans, always take the opportunity of abortion or something like that to attack our human rights, to critisize our human rights. It is all nonsense. Each country has its own culture and its own situation. You cannot always see us in your own way. You had better change you mind, think about the situation that we faced, are facing, and will face, then everthing will be OK.
Where are you from Z?
You don't say, and I won't assume.
From all sources I have read and watched, the single child policy is vastly unpopular amongest the people in China.
For the most recent reference I can site...go to npr.org
about 2 weeks ago was a long segment from China, by the Chinise expressing their unhappiness. I cannot guarantee that particular story is still ative, you may have to look in their archives. In it, one of the familys interviewed we discribing how their daughter was forcible removed from her home, and forced to have an abortion.
The documentary, which I watched perhaps up to 5 years ago...I cannot remember it's name. It was on television. It was not a sensationalist show. It showed very clearly small children in orphanages, dozens of them, tied to chairs, banging their heads against wooden braces provided to keep them from standing up, causing oozing sores. They were sitting in chairs with the bottoms cut out, fecal matter from obviously several days piled under them. These children began life as totally healthy human beings, and they were brought to this end, half dead physically, totally dead spiritually.
You speak of cultural differences.....China does not have a culture that does not love it's children.
This reminds me of a song of Sting, entitled "I hope the Russians love their Children Too." The subject matter of the song is completely different from what we are discussing here....but it does bring up the point that no matter what culture a person is from....they love their children.
If you are interested....google the terms 'china dying rooms' or 'china one child policy'
You will come up with plenty of information.
Just for the record.....Z.....are you in favor of this one child policy? If so, why? Also, address the question of forced abortions and dying rooms, which is not a lie, as I have seen it with my own eyes.
I am not discussing abortion per se here, that is an individuals choice, and it's not what this thread is about. I am addressing the fact that women who do not want this procedure are being forced to have it, and unwanted children are dying horrible deaths.
Surely China can come up with an alternative to this. It is not what the people want. They love their children too.
Hickory, you in particular, look this stuff up, it's a real eye opener. I can tell you're a seeker, like me. I'd appreciate your thoughts on this after studying.