JLNobody wrote:Back to the thread's question about the meaning of life. The issue is, as I see it, not whether or not there is meaning or are meanings in our lives--we experience them all the time. The issue is their source: do they come from God, or some other supernatural source or are they OUR creations. I vote for the latter. No meanings (even geometric axioms) are a priori. At the most they are generated by the structure of our neurology and our cultural conditioning. But they do not exist independent of human action and makeup.
Sorry to be such a fuddy duddie.
That's the big question, eh. And I've been thinking more and more about this. Which probably says more about MY state than anything else! Things that are unpleasant to me tend to get me thinking about this, and I suspect I am not alone in that.
Who are we?!
.......I think that answers 'the meaning of life'.
If we think of ourselves as seperate somehow from god(s) and the supernatural, then the question becomes either/or.
But need it be? By saying "that is god" "this is me" or "Meaning comes from God" "Meaning comes from me", we are just making more distinctions of our experience as human beings.
I've always felt torn. "spiritual' 'godly' 'mystical' experiences seem real to me....but I can't bring myself to say "Oh yes, a god or goddesses exists" because ....well, that's just me putting those experiences into a form. I don't actually see a god or spirits, but i experience things I can not understand or put my head around.
But I can't deny how much richer life is when I do not identify myself strictly as a physical body with neurons and all these other things...but also as a big mystery even to myself....maybe that mystery is god..
I'm not really making an arguement or anything, just processing.