Reply
Sat 21 Jan, 2006 02:33 pm
Antonio Davis of the NY Knicks has been suspended and fined for leaving the court when he saw that his wife was being assaulted/harrassed/manhandled by two men in the stands.
While I agree that an athlete should never leave the court or field to interact with people in the stands, and appreciate the hefty fines, especially after that ugly fight last season between players and a fan, something else was happening here and I think Mr. Davis' suspension and the fine are way too heavy.
What do you think? Should he have left the court? Should he have been fined and suspended? Do you think the fact that one of her alledged assaulters is a politician's son has anything to do with his getting benched?
Antonio Davis
Weird.
From that account, it sounds like it's reasonable and not something that deserves such a hefty punishement. I'm not sure if it's the politician's son part that got him benched so much as zero tolerance/ making an example out of him, since it's a fairly new policy.
eoe- I know very little about professional sports, and never heard about Antonio Davis. The only thing that I could say, is that if Davis thought that his wife was in harm's way, he did the right thing to attempt to get the guy away from her, and damn the team rules.
It was a split second decision. I think that Davis should have gotten a slap on the wrist for going against the rules of the team, but I think that his punishment WAS unreasonable.
Me too. A little fine, maybe a one game suspension, just to make their point, but if I was young Mr. Axlerod's father, instead of watching him file lawsuits, I would be in his ass about whatever was going on between him and Mrs. Davis during the game. Whatever was said should not have escalated to such a degree.
Never got a clear understanding about the other guy who supposedly put his hands on her. Where did he come from and why was he involved?
Davis did what any husband would have. He ran to the defense of his wife.
Under the circumstances I believe the league over reacted.
Where were the ushers in all this. It seems to me that family members of players should be protected from the kind of harassment his wife was subject to.
Seems as if she was sitting seven rows up in the stands instead of further down behind the players bench, where most wives sit. It's safer to sit down there, for this very reason, but from that spot, you really don't get a good view of the court.
A person's right to defend members of his family is absolute.
Acquiunk wrote:Where were the ushers in all this. It seems to me that family members of players should be protected from the kind of harassment his wife was subject to.
Ever since that incident they have had security in place for the families and, I believe, are keeping them in special secluded sections.
Antonio Davis did the right thing, but it could have been a problem to let him go without a punishment. Both sides, it seems, did what they had to. It's unfortunate, but that's how the world works, eh?
But five games?? He'll lose $700,000 in total (boohoo

) but that's alot of moolah to lose for defending your family.
I agree that the suspension is excessive... I can understand why the league wants to keep player out of the stands, but under these circumstances, he did the right thing. Hopefully he will win the appeal.
From what I've read and heard Mr. Davis' wife is a royal pain in the ass. The men involved in the alledged assault were asking for security long before the incident occured.
Where did you read and hear this? Links please.
Davis Gets 5 Games for Entering Stands By BRIAN MAHONEY, AP Basketball Writer
Fri Jan 20, 6:25 AM ET
NEW YORK - Antonio Davis has never been one to cause trouble ?- until he thought his wife was in danger. When Davis responded by climbing into the stands, he did more than jump across the scorer's table: He crossed a line the NBA won't tolerate, no matter the reason.
Especially after the brawl in Detroit.
Davis was suspended five games by the league Thursday for entering the stands during a game in Chicago to confront a fan he thought was harassing his wife.
Though everyone from fellow players to the man who handed down the punishment thought Davis was justified in his concern for his wife, the league made it clear it just can't allow that kind of action after what happened in Detroit in November 2004.
"Certainly the message was very clear after the Nov. 19 incident in that it was clear to our players that they were not to enter the stands under any circumstances," NBA vice president of basketball operations Stu Jackson said. "Certainly this suspension is evident to the fact that we're very serious about that declaration. We realize there were some mitigating circumstances and we did in fact take that into account."
Jackson said those circumstances cut what would've been a penalty of "double-digit games" in half.
But those circumstances remain in dispute.
Davis' statement after the game said the man he thought was threatening his wife, Kendra, was drunk. But that fan, 22-year-old Michael Axelrod, said all he had was a glass of wine at dinner.
Axelrod's attorney, Jay Paul Deratany, said he planned to sue Davis and his wife for more than $1 million. Deratany said he was writing the papers Thursday for a battery suit against Kendra Davis and a slander case against Antonio Davis, and planned to file them Friday.
Axelrod's father, David, is a prominent Democratic political consultant in Chicago who has worked with Sens. Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton and Chicago Mayor Richard M. Daley.
Axelrod said the problems were caused by Kendra Davis.
According to Axelrod, he was sitting in the seventh row and booed an official's call. Kendra Davis "came out of her seat. I didn't even pay attention to her. I thought she was just going to the bathroom or something," he said.
Axelrod said Kendra Davis put both hands on his face, and that he motioned for security. He said she later went after another fan.
"I was glad she was done hitting me, but I didn't want her to hit anyone else," Axelrod said.
Saying he didn't think security could react quickly enough ?- the Knicks' top security official was not available at the time, having left the court to escort Maurice Taylor to the locker room after Taylor was ejected from the game moments earlier ?- Antonio Davis went into the seats to confront Axelrod.
"When I go to games, I cheer as hard as I can for the Bulls, and I boo as hard as I can for whoever they're playing," Axelrod said. "I don't feel comfortable if players are allowed to easily jump into the crowd whenever they feel like it's necessary."
The NBA certainly doesn't want it either, not after all the bad press its players got after Indiana's Ron Artest and Stephen Jackson rushed into the stands at the Palace of Auburn Hills.
"It brings to light the danger when a player enters the spectator stands," Stu Jackson said. "At that point, we lose control of the situation and anything could have happened."
Fortunately for all parties, Davis seemed to remain calm ?- though Axelrod said he used obscenities. Davis has a strong reputation: He is the president of the players' association, was given the Sears Community Service Award for philanthropic efforts for the 1999-00 season, and purchases 32 tickets for each home game for different community groups that may not otherwise have the opportunity to attend games.
"He's obviously concerned about his public perception, concerned with how people perceive and evaluate him," union director Billy Hunter said. "Antonio is a pretty level guy. He's very respectful, very disciplined and extremely close to his family, his wife and children. I can't say anything but positive things about him. And I think he's highly respected around the league."
Davis started his suspension Thursday night in a 105-79 loss to the Pistons, and Hunter said he will lose nearly $700,000 in salary. Davis is allowed to practice with the Knicks, but can't appear at the arena during games.
Hunter said he thought a fine would have been enough, or at most a two-game ban. He said the union will appeal the decision to commissioner David Stern, and was one of the many people at Madison Square Garden who thought Davis' actions were understandable considering what he thought was happening.
"I could understand the league's point of view, but I'd like to put Stu Jackson or David Stern or one of those guys in that situation and see how they would have reacted," Knicks coach Larry Brown said. "I'm amazed at the restraint he had."
Brown was Detroit's coach the night of the brawl, and said there was no comparison between the events. Former Pacers star Reggie Miller and Pistons center Ben Wallace said the same, and none could blame Davis for what he did.
"I think the manner in which he hit the stands is totally different from what went on last year," Wallace said. "We have played together in the World Games a couple of times. I had a chance to meet him and his family. I know what type of person he is and the way he carries himself.
"I know if it happened again tonight and he was playing, he would do the same thing. You got to protect your family."
Now I realize this is pretty much his side of the story. I've also heard on a couple of sports talk radio shows (both in Los Angeles and New York) that Mrs Davis behavior has been less than "stellar". Hence no sources on this
Well, there's two sides to every story, that's for certain.