dagmaraka wrote:I can understand that, momma. But you have to take into account that War in Iraq is a political matter - and even a 'prayer for troops' or civilians - is thus highly politicized in our current atmosphere - outside of a2k just as much. It is thus natural that 'non-religious' folk come there and express their opinions as well. You can't draw the line between political and religious as neatly as Brooke is suggesting.
The Iraq War itself is a political matter, but I fail to see how a prayer for the troops can be "highly politicized." Prayer for the troops is not showing support for the war. I also don't see how this thread was political at all, unless you folks are offended that the thread originator has an American flag for his/her avatar ....
What I'm seeing are the posts of those who don't believe in god, and seem to be offended that prayer is going on. Msolga's early post about the "
influx of dubious religious zealots" conveys that message to me. She poo-poos posts asking for prayer as not being "intelligent," and characterizes them as the posts of those with "
interesting religious beliefs." I fail to see how someone starting a thread seeking group prayer for any group can be construed as "shoving religion down our throats."
It strikes me as more than a little hypocritical to read non-believers on the one hand exclaim that they should not feel constrained from posting in these threads, and then on the other hand attempt to limit the free speech of those that are interested in the subject matter of the thread. You tell me which party is being the most considerate toward the other?
Frankly, if you don't like it, I suggest you don't click on the thread. It seems to me your options are: (a) ignore the thread, or (b) join the thread, and proceed to denigrate those of faith, and attempt to place restrictions on the free expression of ideas on this forum.
As you say ... "Courtesy you expect is unrealistic and unjustified." With attitudes like those displayed in this thread, I believe it is certainly not realistic to expect.