@InfraBlue,
Funny! "You're obtuse" is definitely an ad hominem
.
Let's take these examples.
1.
You are a moron.
2.
You are wrong because because the facts clearly show that pork is a white meat.
3.
That statement is racist because it ignores the historical facts
4.
You are responding in an angry way, but that isn't warranted
In my understanding of "ad hominem" a statement has to be an attack on a person. It can't be an attack on their ideas, or their specific behavior. Under this definition... #1 is an ad hominem. The rest aren't ad hominems (#2 and #3 are attacking facts and arguments, and #4 is attacking a specific emotional response).
If you call one of my statements "racist", I can deal with it. I may listen to your reasoning (or not). But you are commenting on a
specific example. We can discuss and disagree on that one point without affecting our ability to think rationally and objectively on other points.
But if you say that
I am a racist... then you will likely reject all of my arguments whether they are good arguments or not. Believe or not, sometimes I happen to make a good point (there are times when even Izzy agrees with me).
Which examples do you believe are ad hominems? (If everything is an ad hominem to you, then the term doesn't mean anything).,