@edgarblythe,
Jeez!
Sounds like a Wild West situation!
I love the part where he looked confused and said "enough"
Here's 2 stories re paychecks from me.
I didn't distrubute paychecks, but sometimes someone would come to me about a pay question, and I was happy to help.
This new guy saw me helping someone, and so he waited for me to be done and said "my checks wrong"
Now there were all kinds of shift differentials and different rates for weekends etc. so it could be confusing. No ones check was ever the same 2 times in a row, but people obviously had an idea how much it would be.
Since he was new, I went into the system with him and he verified all the hours and shifts he worked were correct, and based on that, his check was perfect. He seemed a little put off by this, but oh well.
Anyway, every week after that he would come to me with the same complaint. If it wasn't the hours, it was the deductions, or why were the taxes different, etc.
Finally I watched him talking with someone in the hallway, holding his check envelope. He opened it while talking, and hadn't looked at it yet. He turned and saw me, and said "Oh! My check is wrong!"
I told him I saw that he hadn't even looked at it yet, and he actually said "Well, no, but it's wrong"
I was done. I told him he should look at the check, and once he figured out what he thought he should have made, and why, I'd check into it.
He never approached me again.
Now this guy, by that time everyone had realized he was a pot stirrer, so I knew it was just his nature.
The other guy though, give me a break.
I worked for the regional director, and he came up to me saying he wanted to talk to her about how the company was "cheating him"
I asked him how, and he said that when he got his last raise, he had received a 65 cent an hour raise, and he should have received 65.31 cents.
Ok I said. That's .0031 cents. Not even a 1/3 of a penny and hour. Really?
He was indignant and said yes, he had children to raise and how was he supposed to feed them if he was being cheated? (beside the point, I so wanted to suggest he stop tithing to whatever whack a doodle church he talked about all the time, and he'd have the money, but I refrained)
What I did say (while whipping out a calculator) was "Ok, you work 2 12 hour shifts a week. I know you don't work every single week, but let's just call it 52 weeks). So (tapping keys), that's 24 hours times 52 is 1248 hours a year (he worked probably more like 1000). Take that times .0031 cents and....that $3.87 cents the company owes you for the year.
Rather than being like "oh...yeah forget it" He actually smirked and said "YES! I'm owed that."
I said I would send an email to payroll in another state, but that wasn't good enough. He said that we had been making interest off his money that whole year, and wasn't going to wait any longer.
I reached into my bag, pulled out $5 and said "Fine. Here. Take this $5 and when payroll gives you an adjustment you can give it back to me. And yes, I'll make sure next time you get a raise they round it up to the next penny." Then I looked at the clock and told him he'd been in my office for 15 or 20 minutes, and had he punched out before he came to talk to me. He said no, so I said let's just forget that he'd just spent that time not doing patient care.
I couldn't believe he actually took the $5. But that's not the end.
I called payroll. Our payroll person and I happened to have developed a really close work relationship over the years. She howled in laughter about the whole thing and said sure, she'd add on the retro pay of $3.87, and put add an entire penny to his rate.
Next payday, I saw him and asked him if he had gotten his back pay, and the extra cent on his rate, and he said yes he had.
"Great, then you can just give me back my $5, and we're done"
"HUH? What? You want ME to give YOU $5!!!??"
I just said I knew he didn't want to cheat me out of money owed to me. He told me he didn't have any money on him right now. I told him I'd remind him next shift he worked.....which I did.
I don't think he was ever really clear why he needed to give me that money.
Whack a doodle.