@maporsche,
maporsche wrote:
As much as I hate Trump if it fixes the DACA kids futures. Improves the health care law or makes it cheaper while protecting the core of the law. Helps balance the bidget while still protecting social safety nets......well good, I think?
Of course Trump will take credit, but if it improves the lives of Americans then ok.
DACA is a political trap on multiple levels:
1) it seduces people into registering as potential deportees, which helps government (threaten) deportation when it serves their interests to do so.
2) it only offered very limited protection to a very limited class of people, so it basically just created a way to hold these kids' future's hostage for political bargaining. There would be an endless procession of negotiations to variously expand or chip away at the program, which would depend on various quid-pro-quo offers in government.
As much as I hate to admit it, after watching European migration and xenophobia interplay for years, my conclusion is that there is just no way to stop these nationalist nations from playing economic games with migrants' lives and futures. They allow them to come when the economy is good and push them to leave when the economy is cooling down.
Until there is a whole-hearted acceptance of migration as a normal part of human existence, the best way for migrants to avoid getting exploited is to stay where they/we have citizenship. Maybe one day the world will come around, but even if/when they do, it's going to take a lot to establish the trust necessary for people who have been burnt by migrant-exploitation to think about moving someplace where they are deprived of full citizenship.
The people who keep taking the risk are those who are so desperate for whatever reason that they are willing to submit to exploitation in hopes that the rewards/benefits of doing so will be better than what they can expect staying put where they are citizens. It is a very sad situation and it is irritating when Democrats act like DACA or any other puny measure they propose solves it. They are just trying to pay lip service in order to relieve their consciences for the exploitations that enable their privileged lives as citizens who don't have to (try to) migrate for a better life.