JLNobody wrote:Monti, I had a similar problem as a child. I was "hyperactive" and couldn't concentrate, except on comic books (which helped to learn to read, and fantasies; I was terrible in math (for understandable reasons). My first 12 years of school were a disaster. I got As and art and music (I was concert master of the junior high school orchestra) but Ds and low Cs in everything else. I never remember doing any homework. And when we were given the Iowa Test, I remember deciding to just mark the answers randomly so that I did not have make the effort (the test failed to measure effort/attitude).
Anyway, there were no concepts of hyperactivity, ADD and ADHD in those days, so they left me alone (truly a case of benign neglect).
As it turned out I couldn't get into a university after high school and so I went to art school and continued my studies of the violin. One day when I was 27 I met an American junior college professor vacationing in Mexico City. He talked me into giving junior college a try. I did and soon ended up with a Ph.D. from a major university--without ritalin.
Expect a lot from your boy, and not much from the "authorities."
I also have two friends who were diagnosed as children with significant degrees of retardation. One ended up being the dean of a college in my university and the other became a well known researcher and provost of a different university.
I admire you advocacy on behalf of your son.
In some cases, however, parents can harm their children when some ideological committment causes them to decline needed and legitimate medical treatment for their children's life threatening disease. It is hard, I guess, to distinguish the good from the less good expressions of resistance.
JL, I'm glad everything worked out for you and your friends. Of course I would have never kept needed medication from my son, but Ritalin certainly wasn't needed.
6 months before I left the US, I bought a webTV and was on the internet for the first time, where I did extensive research on Ritalin and what I learned about the dangers of the drug totaly blew my mind.
I couldn't believe the government wanted me to give this to my little boy!
My son wasn't even hyperactive. He just couldn't get the math.
When we got to Canada, I decided to home school my son and I was amazed at what he did know. After years of the schools having me believe that he was having trouble in all areas, I found that the only problem he had was with math and I had no problem teaching him in that area.
The schools didn't want to supply the funding to put my son in a special class for math with less students, so they decided it was easier to drug him.
The schools didn't have any authority to suggest any medication for my son, yet they did and they did often.
The more I fought, the more they made calls to DSS.
The school counselor told my son one day that I had given up on him because I wasn't willing to give the "medication (Ritalin)" a chance.
I can't even describe what these people did to my our emotional state and I will never, ever forget.
My son is 19 now and gosh, darnit, he survived without Ritalin
Amen!