@realjohnboy,
Johnboy you are succumbing to the narrative of Democrat propaganda (you pompous little git):
"These are all proposals that Republicans have supported in the past!"
Like any good propaganda there is probably some truth to the statement, but it clearly is misinformation intended to paint the Republicans as utter partisan hacks if they don't agree to Obama's proposals.
You're a smart guy, do you really believe that isn't the case?
A great number of Republicans can support the proposal of payroll tax cuts. They may not support Obama's plans for political reasons, or they may pass this one element for political reasons, but it is naive to suggest that either party is approaching this problem without any political consideration. I just don't believe you are this naive.
Tax credits of any sort for hiring are ludicrous.
If you actually need to hire a new employee you will, irrespective of any Obama plan.
If you don't need to hire an employee or you are afraid of the impact of hiring on your business you will not, irrespective of any plan. The tax credit will not offset the cost of a new employee.
No matter how you slice it, Obama's plan will not provide an economic wash, let alone a gain, to anyone who hires someone new who they don't actually need. The primary way this could possibly benefit an employer is if he intended to let the employee go as soon as he realized the tax benefit. Not much of a sustainable Jobs Program.
I suppose there might be a few employers out there who right now can make a case for hiring 80% of a new FTE, and with the tax credit, they'll take the plunge on a full one, but how many such opportunities do you believe exist. Certainly not millions and probably not even thousands.
It's all smoke and mirrors.
For the Obama bait and switch to work, he had to propose some aspects of a plan that Republicans might agree to.
If everything he proposed was clearly in conflict with Republican principles who might believe that the Republicans are thwarting his initiative simply for partisan purposes.
In all likelihood, the Republican House will approve several, but not all, of his proposals. I'm sure Obama would prefer them to reject the proposal in its entirety, but he will still try to make hay as respects "The Party of No".