ehBeth, check out the reviews of the Washington Square Hotel on tripadvisor.com:
Washington Square Hotel - reviews on tripadvisor
The reviews are all over the map, which probably isn't very helpful, but there they are, for what they're worth.
There used to be a very nice restaurant called CIII (Roman numerals for 103, as in 103 Waverly Place, the hotel's address) in the ground floor of the hotel, where I used to eat lunch back when I worked near Washington Square (and where I once saw Quentin Crisp having lunch), but I seem to remember hearing that the restaurant has changed hands since then, so I can't vouch for whatever is there now.