Hi, I started a thread three month ago, but I don't understand the final answer of it.
That was the question:
".........If you read this conversation:
Bryan: Is that an old photo of your friend?
Cathy: No.
Bryan: Okay, I always need to think about that person on the picture, who I thought was your friend. But they are not the same then.
Cathy (looks closer): No they aren't.
In this conversation Cathy's last statement "No they aren't." has the meaning:
"My friend and the person in that picture are two different people. They are not the same person.", correct?"
I was told by many users that this was correct, but the user cicerone imposter told me that I can't draw this conclusion. But I don't unterstand his explanation. Unfortunately he doesn't answer anymore. Can anyone of you help me to understand his explanation?
Link to the explanation: http://able2know.org/topic/308914-3#post-6130253
Bryan: Okay, I always need to think about that person on the picture, who I thought was your friend. But they are not the same then.
Cathy (looks closer): No they aren't.
Here's how I see this:
The "No" is an answer to the first part of the statement: "who I thought was your friend."
The "they aren't" agrees with the observation: "they are not the same then."
Thank you. So in fact you think that in this conversation Cathy's last statement "No they aren't." has the meaning:
"My friend and the person in that picture are two different people. They are not the same person.", correct?
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
Crimson and clover over and over
0 Replies
dylan22
1
Reply
Fri 3 Jun, 2016 07:05 am
@PUNKEY,
Okay, thank you.
So you say that in this conversation Cathy's last statement "No they aren't." has the meaning: "My friend and the person in that picture are two different people. They are not the same person.".