@Robert Gentel,
Robert Gentel wrote:
Brandon9000 wrote:You have the right to this opinion, but it is contrary to America's basic creed. For instance, the Declaration of Independence says:
Quote:We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.
Yet those people thought it was ok to own other people. This is just another thing they got wrong, we are not magically endowed with rights by a creator, they are all rights negotiated within our society and this is just a hyperbolic way of saying they believe very firmly in some fundamental rights.
First of all, my point was that in the US, it is generally believed that the Declaration of Independence is our creed, and the Declaration does describe these rights as inherent. Inherent doesn't have to be interpreted in a religious sense.
Secondly, if society negotiated a set of principles which included the government's right to arrest, punish, and even kill, anyone who spoke out against the laws, most of us would have a feeling that this was not morally good. This indicates that the human condition somehow does produce some common ideas about ethics which most people share, so that it isn't really just a matter of negotiation. It is not true that any set of rights or laws which were negotiated would be viewed by society as the end of the discussion. Most people share a few basic ideas of right and wrong which don't depend on the results of a negotiation. For example, most people feel that any creature has the right to defend itself and its family members. If you do believe this, then it follows that people have the right to the means to defend their own safety and the safety of their families.