@Cycloptichorn,
Cycloptichorn wrote:oralloy wrote:I'd like to see a cite before I accept a claim that the *semi-auto-only* version was ever intended as a weapon of war.
This is immaterial,
If you want to claim that a semi-auto-only AR-15 is a weapon of war, a cite to back up your claim is very much material.
Cycloptichorn wrote:and what more, contradictory to gun-nut messaging. You guys just can't seem to get your story straight on full-autos; one minute, it'll be 'they're hard to hit with so it's ridiculous that they are banned, they should be legal;' the next minute, it's 'full-autos are weapons of war and semis are not, so there's a real difference between the two.'
Both claims seem to be true. Rifle rounds on full-auto require a fixed mount for reasonable accuracy. There is a real difference between full-auto and semi-auto.
What's the problem?
Cycloptichorn wrote:The recent events in Vegas show that this is an meaningless difference anyway, as a semi-auto can fire just as fast as a full-auto and is just as deadly if not more so.
A semi-auto with a bump stock is hardly comparable to a normal semi-auto.
The NRA has already given the government permission to write regulations restricting bump stocks as a form of full-auto.
Cycloptichorn wrote:The fact of the matter is that everything I wrote was accurate: the M-16 was an adaptation of the AR-15, which was a rifle marketed to militaries.
Perhaps a full-auto version of the AR-15 was marketed to militaries. But it is unfair to lump semi-auto-only AR-15s in as having been marketed to militaries.
Cycloptichorn wrote:And it should be banned,
You can't give a single good reason for banning the semi-auto-only version. I know this because no such reason exists.
This is Constitutionally significant too. Laws are only permitted to impact a Constitutional right if the government can demonstrate a compelling reason for having the law.
Cycloptichorn wrote:as it's nothing more than a weapon of warfare and toy for wannabe soldier gun-nuts.
That is incorrect. It is used for hunting, self defense, and competitive sport.