@Olivier5,
Quote:Okay, so a man wanting to debate feminism with a woman is necessarily a patriarchal stooge. Case closed. I won't disturb you anymore with my innate misogyny. Bye now.
That response shows little awareness or understanding of what I was saying to you in the post you were responding to. In no way, was I saying you were misogynist, or a "patriarchal stooge", I said you have blind spots in your thinking about some issues because you fail to understand them from a female perspective, and you need to listen to women, and hear them, if you want to understand why their views differ from yours---I wasn't talking about feminism at all.
What I said was:
I'm not sure you understand or differentiate between feminism and simply women's views and perspectives--they are not synonymous...
I want women to be heard and listened to--otherwise you cannot understand the female perspective on issues based on their life experiences as women. And I don't find you to be a particularly good listener to even the women in this thread. You may respond, to them or to me, but I don't think you really hear what was said, or consider it.
For instance, you keep asserting that patriarchy doesn't exist, you called it tilting at windmills, and you dismiss it as some sort of feminist delusion, but ehBeth, osso, and I, all disagreed with you. Did that cause you to consider you might be wrong? No, you went right on making the same assertion as though you didn't hear us. That's not just a difference of opinion, it's a blind spot you might have as a man because patriarchy doesn't affect you, it privileges you, or it certainly doesn't affect you in the way it would if you were a woman.
Forget about feminism, Oliver, you really don't seem to understand it anyway, and just start listening to women, really listening, if you want to understand where their heads are at. I think you might have lots of male blind spots you aren't even aware of.
http://able2know.org/topic/262626-13#post-5877798
This is essentially no different than saying to a white person in the U.S. they have to start listening to black people, and try to understand the black perspective and experience, if they really want to understand the complaints of the black community about racial profiling, or discriminatory attitudes, or injustice. White people in this country are not subjected to the same life experiences as blacks on the basis of their skin color. If they don't listen to blacks they will never understand the complaints because their perceptions and thought will continue to be riddled with blind spots. All of that polarization became abundantly clear during the Zimmerman case. Even when the President weighed in on his experiences as a black man, which related to racial profiling, there were people who refused to listen and hear him, and called him another "race-baiter".
If men want to understand why women might perceive issues, and situations, and behaviors, differently than they do, they have to listen to women and try to understand their perspective, and their life experiences, just as whites have to listen to blacks and try to understand their perspective on how they view the police, and how they are treated by the police, for instance, based on their life experiences.
If either racial or gender groups want to move beyond adversarial positions, reduce conflicts between then, and effect change from a status quo that may be maintaining inequality, they have to listen
empathetically to the complaining group. That's what effects change. For instance, once straight people in this country began listening to the gay and lesbian community present the issue of same sex marriage from a civil rights perspective, and could understand and identify with it in those terms, their blind spots began shrinking and support for same sex marriage gained enormous strength.
And, it goes without saying that women should listen to men, and their gender perspective, on issues like child custody.
None of this means that everyone will wind up agreeing with each other, particularly on how to resolve existing problems, but really listening to each other will help to improve communication and understanding by gaining the other group's perspective on what the problems are.
Quote:The worse thing is that firefly and I actually and objectively agree on many points. But since I am a man, she won't listen to me nor understand a word I say. All she wants is to write walls of text scolding me.
Don't accuse me of not listening to you because you are a man, because that's just not true. I listen to you quite carefully, I have no difficulty, at all, understanding what you say, and I see blind spots in your thinking because you tend to disregard, dismiss, or ignore, the female perspective on issues, like whether we live in a patriarch, even when they are voiced in this thread by a number of women. That's a comment I am addressing specifically to you, not on the basis of your gender, or because you are a man, but because I see a narrowness in your personal thinking on gender issues.
And none of this has anything to do with feminism, a topic I'm not really particularly interested in discussing, and one you are not particularly well informed about. I'm more interested in promoting better communication and understanding between the genders, and you're the one who's misunderstanding where I'm coming from.