1) This has to stop. Jessie tried to reason with herself. Pull your hand away now, she instructed herself forcefully. Now! Her inner voice screamed.
2) Jessie stared after his retreating back and thought, if my life is a rom com, shouldn’t he turn around and ask me to marry him?
3) Like they were thinking, this is it. Jessie has finally found the one.
The punctuation would be easier to figure out if you used quotation marks for speech and thoughts.