@McTag,
McTag: You, on the other hand, would encourage foreigners to trip over ever more cumbersome phrases. I've seen you at it. Unnecessary overcomplication is your stock-in-trade. Less is often more. "Keep it simple" is a good adage, for the learners we deal with here.
----------------
Many of the learners here ask questions that completely flummox you. You are so out of your depth you don't know if you are coming or going.
So who would be better to decide that, McTag, someone with, say, a quarter century of teaching experience or you with (___) years of teaching experience?
You have a beginner's pattern of thinking that you can teach a language by "correcting" a student's sentence with McTag's version of simplicity when you can't see the forest for the trees, when you don't even know the forest exists or what it looks like or how it all interacts.