Tarantulas wrote:That is absolutely true. Gun laws only apply to people who obey the law. Criminals, by definition, disobey laws. It is SO SIMPLE that I don't understand why some of the gun control people don't smack themselves in the forehead and give up trying to make more restrictive laws.
Since there are some criminals who do obey guns laws, I should have said "Gun laws only apply to people who obey gun laws. People who disobey gun laws are, by definition, criminals."
Craven de Kere wrote:"Gun-control" doesn't rely on the trustworthiness of law breakers any more than any other law. "Only law-abiding citizens obey laws against murder" is also just as true and the statement does not have relevance to the validity of laws against murder. For its viability it needs to be enforced to compel the reluctant to comply.
Similarly, you should have said "Only criminals disobey laws against murder," since non-murderous criminals do obey laws against murder.
Craven de Kere wrote:Whether or not it can be realized in America is a good question and the saying does have a point in that the law's enforcement would have to be viable. I think the staunch opposition to it by so many generally law-abiding citizens would hamper the ability to use the law-abiding majority to dry up the sources for the criminal minority. That's why I'm not too keen on the idea stateside. Culture itself would have to change for it to be possible.
The avowed goals of some of the gun control groups is to take firearms out of the hands of private citizens. With that in mind, almost any new gun law looks to a gun owner like the next step on the road to confiscation. So a gun owner looks at a proposed new law with at least two things in mind:
1. Is the problem solved by this law an actual problem, or a made-up problem?
2. How will this law affect law-abiding gun owners?
It seems that in most cases, the answer to #1 is that it's a made-up problem, and the answer to #2 is that the law restricts certain freedoms. So gun owners urge their representatives to "vote agin it!"
Here's my duty weapon. A Sig Sauer P228 9mm. Engineered Reliability!