Reply
Fri 9 Apr, 2004 06:49 pm
Carla van Raay, who was born in Holland in 1938 but moved to Australia as a child, joined a Melbourne convent as a way of escaping a traumatic childhood. But after a number of conflicts with other nuns, she left and briefly became a teacher before embarking on a long-term life offering sex for money.
Ms van Raay told BBC World Service's Everywoman programme she had had "tremendous fun" at first, but ended up finding the profession degrading and humiliating.
"I would not recommend it to anyone," she said.
"The way I started off was with very high ideals and a great deal of naivety, and I didn't end up that way.
"I felt degraded in the end, and all the guilt that was inside me came to the surface and I felt guilty and shameful. I was in a bad way."
'The Devil was my only friend'
Now 65, Ms van Raay has been celibate for 12 years.
She said that many of the reasons behind her actions in her life related to the abuse she suffered as a child.
"When I came to Australia I thought I was in paradise - it was such a bright, sunny country," she explained.
"It was pretty grim in Holland... I was abused as a child. But because I adjusted when I was little, because children do, and I loved my father. But when he wanted to silence me, at the age of 6, he did something very drastic.
"He told me not to go to confession, because in confession I might tell the priest what he was up to with me, and he didn't want anyone to know."
She added that her interpretation of her father's action was that she was "the baddest girl in the world" and that God had abandoned her.
"The Devil was my only friend," she said.
"I was extremely desolate after that."
As a result of the experience, Ms van Raay said she joined the convent, stating that she had become withdrawn and wanted to pull away from life.
But also said she felt a strong vocational feeling that "it was the right thing to become a nun."
"But the fact of the matter also was that I wasn't able to face life. I didn't know what relationships were all about. I didn't know anything about the world."
Friction
In total, Ms van Raay stayed 12 years in the convent. She said that at first she was happy, but the laws became stricter.
The big change, however, was when the Vatican passed laws allowing nuns greater freedom to speak their minds.
While Ms van Raay was in favour of these changes, other sisters were not. She said the friction created by this eventually caused her to leave.
Shortly afterwards she began work as a teacher in Melbourne's biggest school. After six months she had "scotched" religion. She stayed in the school another year, before getting married - but it did not last.
"When I got married, I married a man who was a very good man, and one whom I tried to love," she said.
"But because I'd had no experience of a boyfriend before, and no experience of life in general, it was inevitable that I would have a tempestuous affair with a 19-year-old.
"That broke up the marriage, and I was alone with a child."
She admitted this was "not a good excuse" for becoming a prostitute.
But she said that there was "sexual confusion" inside her that made her think of doing so, "that made me want to explore my sexuality in this way."
No regrets
The trigger for her taking up prostitution, she said, was when she saw migrant women making raincoats in a factory.
Ms van Raay came to Melbourne in 1950
"I thought to myself, 'these women are prostituting themselves for a few dollars an hour'," she said.
"As soon as the word came into my mind, I thought, well, I can prostitute myself as well, but I'll make good money and I'll have fun at the same time."
Ms van Raay is now working on a second book, entitled In Praise Of Prostitution.
She said that she had now "exonerated" her father, and that she was now the happiest she had ever been.
"When I finally faced everything inside me and realised I was none of these dreadful things I had been feeling about myself, I have been at peace and enjoyed myself very much," she said.
"Now I don't have any regrets. I'm grateful for my life - because it was only on account of everything I suffered that I woke up to myself."
Looks like this nun's habit got a little dirty.
Sad story, but the nun eventually grew up, it seems.
I don't think that it is so unusual for a child who has been traumatized to seek shelter in a convent or a monastery. It has been done before, and will happen again. That she left, and then acted out sexually, is not unusual either.
The good news of the story, is that she had the strength of character to enable her to "get it all together", everntually. I say, "good for her!"
I can't help but wonder, how many prostitutes end up becoming nuns!
truth
And I wonder, Phoenix, how many traumatized girls seek shelter from pimps.
Miller wrote:I can't help but wonder, how many prostitutes end up becoming nuns!
Ever heard of "Magdalen Houses?"
Horrible story, hobitbob. I can hardly believe it was true. I didn't watch it... the shorts and the review were enough to turn me away.
Could this ex-nun-woman be making up a story? I don't think most prostitutes consider their work 'fun.' That doesn't ring true. Neither does exonerating her father.
Stumble It!
Tweet This
Bookmark on Delicious
Share on Facebook
Share on MySpace