Re: unattractiveness?
You're a good sport dude. I'm glad.
Suggestion 1) Get on with your life: Use this suggestion if you believe what I said already. (I may not have been correct as to which dream girl you were referring.)
Suggestion 2) One last try: Use this suggestion if you're not sure, and want to be sure. What difference does it make if you look less attractive, to someone who isn't attracted in the first place? (The ones who get snookered back in by jealousy are unlikely to be your soul mate anyway.) Take the closure, if you need the peace of mind.
Either way; I'm guessing the result will be the same. Don't take it personally. That's just silly. Some guys get so caught up in rejection that they can only approach one girl a night with a shred of confidence. You can literally see them shrink before your eyes if a girl doesn't want to dance.
Now if their closing ratio is 1 in 10 (average); that means they have to go out 10 times to meet one girl.
Usually, if girls are not interested in a cool guy, they have legitimate reasons and it isn't even about you. 90% will be flattered and courteous whether they are interested or not, so what is there to be ashamed of?
You sound like you're tired of not having a girlfriend. Let's say for the sake of conversation that you get average results when flirting with women (1 in 10). Do you have to go out 10 times to say hello to 10 women? I don't. After years in sales the word "no" has no sting to it. I could get rejected by 20 women in a single evening and still have time to enjoy myself with lucky number 21.
Years ago, before I developed a little etiquette, I had gotten one of those bad reputations for dating to many co-workers. Pretty girls were warned day one that I was a "philanderer". One beautiful girl told me after dinner that the only reason she went out with me was to see if she could handle herself with the office pig (ouch). I laughed and told her she was doing a fine job. She said she didn't know how to interpret the results (over breakfast the next morning :wink: ).
My point is; stop scheming. Living is much more fun. Don't worry what any particular girl thinks about you. Let them worry about what you think. Introduce yourself to every girl you are attracted to until you find a match... and don't forget to enjoy every step in the process! Good luck!