@FBM,
Quote:I still don't even understand why it matters. Myths have been built up around buttloads of historical people. That question is trivial.
Just like the issue of the historicity of Shakespeare is trivial. What matters are the plays bearing his name.
Even more important for me, is the fact that these controversies never produce any new knowledge; there are totally sterile scientifically. Just like the Global Warming doubters have never contributed anything to our understanding of climatology, the Jesus deniers have contributed nothing to our understanding of this story, or of the Gospels. You can read the Jesus article in a 100-years-old encyclopedia and not find one single point on which modern scholarship is clearly at odd. That debate has raged for years and years, and never produced anything of value...
But perhaps that's precisely the
real aim of these hyper-skeptical polemists: hamper the possibility of knowledge. That's obviously the goal of the GW deniers and their orporate handlers, for instance.