@dalehileman,
Quote:In my day it was rejected on the basis of number or syntax or something,
It was erroneously rejected in that era [18th century] that gave us most of the silly prescriptions that, today, people still pass on without thinking.
You, that's you Dale, still use 'you' as both a singular and a plural - the singular form 'you' with a plural form verb 'are'. No one whines about rejecting singular 'you' on the basis of number, no one complains about using a singular 'you' with a plural verb 'are'. No one complains about singular 'you' on any basis actually.
What of singular 'we'?
Well now, aren't we just the cat's meow?
Don't you think it odd that these grammar geniuses have missed these?
Here's a good hint for those over ten years of age that want to offer advice on language. You can safely assume that for virtually every rule you were ever taught, exposed to, corrected on, there is an excellent chance that it is a complete or partial falsehood.
Sadly, this is particularly true if you were educated in the US.