Reply
Wed 24 Nov, 2010 01:06 am
Fascinating as these findings were = although these findings were fascinating, but...?
Context:
In the lamprey, two different lymphocyte lineages bearing clonally diverse lymphocyte receptors, VLRB and VLRA, were traced as analogs of mammalian humoral B cells and T cells respectively, that mediate B and T cell based antigen-specific adaptive immunity.
Fascinating as these findings were, the sea lamprey offered no evolutionary insights into the mysteries of self-recognition. An issue in later discussions was the distinction between autoimmune diseases caused by adaptive responses due to recombinatorial receptors of T and B cells, and autoinfiammatory diseases due to dysfunctional cells of the mammalian innate immune system.
@oristarA,
Yes.
It's a fairly common construction. Some examples might help:
Beautiful as she was, she did not get the part.
Try as I might, I could not climb the tree.
Fascinating as the results were, they did not help us to solve the problem
@oristarA,
Quote:Fascinating as these findings were = although these findings were fascinating, but...?
Yes and.
No. Either 'these findings were fascinating but' or 'although these findings were fascinating'.
'Although' is not used with 'but' because it would be a tautology.