1
   

Fundalmentalism and Dogma

 
 
Campbell34
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 03:05 pm
@Numpty,
Numpty;42498 wrote:
What you believe is interesting, but if you attach probabality to your theory then what the bible prohpicise's is in fact 'bound to happen' at some point.

Think about it, Jews will return to Isreal and then on to Jerusalem, given they way in which human history has developed is in not easy to predict that at some point in time from the putting together the bible, in the next 1700 years that the jews will return to jerusalem?

C'mon man think of something with a bit more accuracy.

I predict in the Next 2000 years that Britain will once again occupy France.
Now given the previous 1000 years of history betwen the two nations, that is a pretty safe bet.


If that was all there was to it you might have a point. Yet there are other factors. Jerusalems East Gate for one. The Old Jerusalems East Gate was buried, and hundreds of years later non believers used the Old East Gate as a foundation for a New Porch Gate. They did not understanding that they were actually fulfilling a Bible prophecy by adding a Porch Gate. Now this Porch Gate would be the New East Gate for Jerusalem. Also sometime after that, the New Porch Gate was sealed up by non believers in the Bible. Here again, without understand they fulfilled another prophecy. Now hundreds of years later Moslems heard of the prophecy and knew if they could walk through that Gate the Bible would be proven wrong. The reason for that is the Bible stated that all attempts to break through the New Porch Gate would fail. Around 1917, and in 1967 Moslems tried to break through the Gate but failed. And again the Bible was proven correct. Now as we get close to the time of the end the Book of Revelation speaks of an astroid that will strike the sea and kill of one third of the marine life, and destroy one third of the ships in that sea. Now the problem here is that Astroids would not be discovered for another 1700 years. So how could those who wrote the Bible of know about Astroids. Also in the Book of Revelation it states that when the armies of the East rise up to march to Jerusalem their numbers will be 200 million men. Yet at the time the Bible was written I doubt that the whole population of Asia had that many people. Let alone a single army. It was not until 1960 when China boasted that they themselves could raise up an army of 200 million men. And I doubt any of them knew that the Bible had predicted such an army because Bibles had been outlawed in China back then. Also the Bible talks about the earth heating up, and men would curse God because of the heat. Today all you hear about is global warming, just as the Bible predicted. Seeing all these things coming together,there is no way simple men of the Bible could of predicted all of this, unless there was someone out there who knew what was going to happen. The Bible speaks about the coming destruction of America, and it points out it will be a sneak attack. It states that all our cities will burn and be destroyed in one hours time. Also it states our government will refuse to use her weapons. Also stated, that after the destruction, no one will ever be able to return to the land again, not even to remove a stone for a foundation because the land will be fully polluted. It states that after the attack, the moon will turn blood red, and the sun will be dimmed, and the stars will not show their light. That would be the affect of Nuclear winter. There's just to many details to believe this was all predicted by chance. Jesus Christ Himself fulfilled over three hundred prophecies of the Old Testament, and He fulfilled them all literally.
0 Replies
 
Numpty
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 03:15 pm
@Ann cv,
Where does it state the destruction of America.

Plus many scientists believe the global warming is infact a prelude to a new ice age.

Does the bible say asteriods?

If the chinese have had little to no contact with the bible, why would they rise up and decsend up Isreal.
Campbell34
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 04:33 pm
@Numpty,
Numpty;42504 wrote:
Where does it state the destruction of America.

Plus many scientists believe the global warming is infact a prelude to a new ice age.

Does the bible say asteriods?

If the chinese have had little to no contact with the bible, why would they rise up and decsend up Isreal.


The word asteroiod was not coined until many years after the Bible describe one. Revelation 8:8 The second angle sounded his trumpet, and something like a huge mountain, all ablaze, was thrown into the sea. A third of the sea turned into blood, and a third of the living creatures in the sea died, and a third of the ships were destroyed.

It may be that control for middle East Oil will be an incentive for the Chinese. Yet that is just speculation on my part. According to the Bible Islamic nations will target Jerusalem. You can read about the coming war, in Ezekiel chapters 36, 37, 38, and 39. That is in the Old Testament.
Numpty
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 05:28 pm
@Campbell34,
Campbell34;42505 wrote:
The word asteroiod was not coined until many years after the Bible describe one. Revelation 8:8 The second angle sounded his trumpet, and something like a huge mountain, all ablaze, was thrown into the sea. A third of the sea turned into blood, and a third of the living creatures in the sea died, and a third of the ships were destroyed.

It may be that control for middle East Oil will be an incentive for the Chinese. Yet that is just speculation on my part. According to the Bible Islamic nations will target Jerusalem. You can read about the coming war, in Ezekiel chapters 36, 37, 38, and 39. That is in the Old Testament.


Ok,..bearing in mind that in your opinion God can do pretty much as he wants, I am pretty sure the his ability to move a mountain was well with in the realms of possibility by the men that wrote the bible. they need not know of out side asteriods to be able to plot that stoyline. When a mountain is raised in the air and you see it, guess what it be comes something like a huge mountain.

Erm,..Isreal as far as I am aware has very little hold on Oil, that belongs to Saudis and Iraq's, if they were to invade that area, Isreal would be left alone.

who is the second angel?

Oh yeah you did not mention America
mlurp
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 06:49 pm
@Numpty,
hummmmmm i shall pray for all of you if that is alright with each.
Numpty
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 07:38 pm
@mlurp,
mlurp;42521 wrote:
hummmmmm i shall pray for all of you if that is alright with each.


Why do you wish to pray for me?

I need no such action. Pray for your self, but as far as I am aware no matter hoe much you pray for someone else, only Jesus christ can save their soul. So why bother? If I am good he will save me, if not he will know anyway.

Hey remember he knows more than you, so your praying is in vain really.

That is why any religion is so contadictory.
0 Replies
 
Adam Bing
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 10:34 pm
@Campbell34,
Campbell34;41990 wrote:
The Bible clearly teachs that we should not murder, and Christ points out that murders will not enter God's Kingdom. Now there maybe people who put men to death for their ideas, yet these men are not Christians reguardless of who's name they claim the right to murder in. The Christian faith is much different than the Moslem faith. Christians are not slaves to the law, but operate out of the freedom of grace which is light years from the Taliban.
Also the Bible is far from backwards thinking. It's cutting edge prophecies tell you of what is soon going to happen in the world we live in. The Jews are not back in Israel by accident, and the Bible tells us what will happen to Israel and the world in the last days. The Bible tells mankind what God desires of us, yet mankind has set his own path.


You claim the Bible teaches you not to murder. Lets go through Deutoronomy or Exodus line by line and see if you are right.
0 Replies
 
Adam Bing
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 10:43 pm
@Ann cv,
The problem with Fundementalism is that it takes scriptures literally. The term Fundamentalist by the way, was first coined to describe christians who took the Bible literally.

Taking a document frozen in time literally begets problems. This claim of the Bible fortelling us about asteroids is no different from the claims being made in another thread about the Scientific nature of the Koran.

It is funny how violently different the "Campell"s (Christian) and "The Sword of God"s (Muslim) of the world think they are from each other and how similar they appear to the third party non-monotheist observer like me.

As far as I am concerned there is one Monotheist bloc made up of Christians, Muslims and Jews who if not addressed collectively by us innocent bystanders will bring us all down with them in their march towards a man made armeggadon.

We, the rest of the world can no longer take refuge in silence or in following a benign policy of "to each his own".

The Christians, Muslims and Jews ideologies need to be confronted and challenges at every step. They cannot be allowed to get away with any claim without it being subjected to full verification.

We, the innocent bystanders, need to call their bluff.
0 Replies
 
Adam Bing
 
  1  
Reply Sat 20 Oct, 2007 10:52 pm
@Ann cv,
This one is for Mr.Campbell34. Sir, would you classify this edict from Deutoronomy as murder? Please do respond as I am trying to learn about your faith.

" If you hear that in one of the towns which Yahweh your God has given you for a home, there are men, scoundrels from your own stock, who have let their fellow-citizens astray, saying "Let us go and serve other gods," hitherto unknown to you, it is your duty to look into the matter, examine it, and inquire most carefully. If it is proved and comfirmed that such a hateful thing has taken place among you, you must put the inhabitants of that town to the sword; you must lay it under the curse of destruction - the town and everything in it. You must pile up all its loot in the public square and burn the town and all its loot, offering it all to Yahweh your God. It is to be a ruin for all time and never rebuilt". (Deuteronomy 13:12-16).
Campbell34
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 06:47 am
@Numpty,
Numpty;42506 wrote:
Ok,..bearing in mind that in your opinion God can do pretty much as he wants, I am pretty sure the his ability to move a mountain was well with in the realms of possibility by the men that wrote the bible. they need not know of out side asteriods to be able to plot that stoyline. When a mountain is raised in the air and you see it, guess what it be comes something like a huge mountain.

Erm,..Isreal as far as I am aware has very little hold on Oil, that belongs to Saudis and Iraq's, if they were to invade that area, Isreal would be left alone.

who is the second angel?

Oh yeah you did not mention America


If you read the text it states something LIKE a burning mountain, if they believe it to be a mountain, they would of said so. It should be pretty obvious what these men are talking about, that is unless your just trying to rationalize it away which would require a real stretch. Also, a mountain being lifted up some thousands of feet into the air would not be burning, because it requires a great deal of speed and friction to create that kind of heat. Only something that has approached the earths outer atmosphere traveling at thousands of miles per hour could begin to heat up like that.

Also, Israel will not be left alone, because it is the Islamics nations that want Jerusalem, China's involvment is a question mark, yet it will be Russia and the Islamic nations that will try to attack Israel by force. The fact that the Jews are back and now control Jerusalem, and we have a sealed East Porch Gate of Jerusalem, and Iran an Islamic country is now saying Israel should be wiped off the face of the earth, should give one pause. The Bible predicted all of this, and to ignore these facts, would be the height of folly.
0 Replies
 
Campbell34
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 07:04 am
@Adam Bing,
Adam Bing;42548 wrote:
This one is for Mr.Campbell34. Sir, would you classify this edict from Deutoronomy as murder? Please do respond as I am trying to learn about your faith.

" If you hear that in one of the towns which Yahweh your God has given you for a home, there are men, scoundrels from your own stock, who have let their fellow-citizens astray, saying "Let us go and serve other gods," hitherto unknown to you, it is your duty to look into the matter, examine it, and inquire most carefully. If it is proved and comfirmed that such a hateful thing has taken place among you, you must put the inhabitants of that town to the sword; you must lay it under the curse of destruction - the town and everything in it. You must pile up all its loot in the public square and burn the town and all its loot, offering it all to Yahweh your God. It is to be a ruin for all time and never rebuilt". (Deuteronomy 13:12-16).


Murder is killing without cause. If God came to me and I knew this was the Creator of the Universe, and if I knew He created me, and He gave me a reason to put another to death, and I knew that reason was true, I would do what my Creator told me to do.
Adam Bing
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 07:15 am
@Campbell34,
Campbell34;42572 wrote:
Murder is killing without cause. If God came to me and I knew this was the Creator of the Universe, and if I knew He created me, and He gave me a reason to put another to death, and I knew that reason was true, I would do what my Creator told me to do.


Its no longer a question of "if " Mr.Campbell. No "if God came to me".

You have here in Deutoronomy, a direct and clear instruction from God. it is not ambiguious and there can be no question of doubt. You need not seek any expert opinion. Deutoronomy is telling you to kill unbelievers and torch their possessions.

So either you believe in the Bible and prepare to kill me or you do not believe in the Bible and refrain from the act of killiing this unbeliever. What is it to be?
Campbell34
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 09:05 am
@Adam Bing,
Adam Bing;42575 wrote:
Its no longer a question of "if " Mr.Campbell. No "if God came to me".

You have here in Deutoronomy, a direct and clear instruction from God. it is not ambiguious and there can be no question of doubt. You need not seek any expert opinion. Deutoronomy is telling you to kill unbelievers and torch their possessions.

So either you believe in the Bible and prepare to kill me or you do not believe in the Bible and refrain from the act of killiing this unbeliever. What is it to be?



Well if we lived back in the time of Deutoronomy and you were one of those unbelievers God told me to kill, I would. And it would not be murder because murder is killing without cause. In this case, I would be doing what the Creator of the Universe told me to do. And God never has anyone do such a thing, unless there is a very good reason for it. When you get to know God, you understand that everything He tells you to do is for the good. And sometimes you don't see it that way, but I got to tell you, God sure has a way about getting His believers to do the right thing. I recall going with a woman 30 years ago before I met my wife. I was going to ask her to marry me, but this woman forgot to tell me she was all ready engaged to this 23 year old guy and soon became his third wife. I wrote her a letter and told her what I though about her when I found out. Would you believe, Just this year God forced me to apologize to her. God has good reasons for doing what He does even if we don't understand them.
Numpty
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 10:05 am
@Campbell34,
Campbell34;42590 wrote:
Well if we lived back in the time of Deutoronomy and you were one of those unbelievers God told me to kill, I would. And it would not be murder because murder is killing without cause. In this case, I would be doing what the Creator of the Universe told me to do. And God never has anyone do such a thing, unless there is a very good reason for it. When you get to know God, you understand that everything He tells you to do is for the good. And sometimes you don't see it that way, but I got to tell you, God sure has a way about getting His believers to do the right thing. I recall going with a woman 30 years ago before I met my wife. I was going to ask her to marry me, but this woman forgot to tell me she was all ready engaged to this 23 year old guy and soon became his third wife. I wrote her a letter and told her what I though about her when I found out. Would you believe, Just this year God forced me to apologize to her. God has good reasons for doing what He does even if we don't understand them.


God forced you to apologise? Ol' Gods seems to be somewhat of a meglomaniac.

As you said something LIKE a mountain of burning fire. When a piece of fiction is written, the writer is given artistic license to expand and exaggerate to the story they are telling. They may not know of Asteriods but you can bet yer bottom dollar they have heard of ,or seen Volcanoes spewing out lava and burning rocks into the atmosphere. How easy is it then to exaggerate that knowledge to something LIKE the size of a mountain.

Your Prophecies can be accounted for using probability that an event will at some point occur. It's the same with Nostradamus, hundreds of prophicies fullfilled because people attach similaraities to generic propersitions. It is the same with the bible, I appreciate you think Nostradamus is as big a nut as i do, but the same can be said of what is written in the bible.
Adam Bing
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 10:19 am
@Campbell34,
Campbell34;42590 wrote:
Well if we lived back in the time of Deutoronomy and you were one of those unbelievers God told me to kill, I would. And it would not be murder because murder is killing without cause. In this case, I would be doing what the Creator of the Universe told me to do. And God never has anyone do such a thing, unless there is a very good reason for it. When you get to know God, you understand that everything He tells you to do is for the good. And sometimes you don't see it that way, but I got to tell you, God sure has a way about getting His believers to do the right thing. I recall going with a woman 30 years ago before I met my wife. I was going to ask her to marry me, but this woman forgot to tell me she was all ready engaged to this 23 year old guy and soon became his third wife. I wrote her a letter and told her what I though about her when I found out. Would you believe, Just this year God forced me to apologize to her. God has good reasons for doing what He does even if we don't understand them.


Mr.Campbell, so are you saying that Deutoronomy is no longer relevant? Because you say you'd kill me if we lived back in the time of Deutoronomy.

I take it then, that you won't kill me now because you feel that Deutoronomy is not relevant in today's world.

You and I Sir, are in perfect agreement then. We have had a meeting of the minds on the fact that the Bible is not relevant in today's world.

But do feel free to retract what you said and we can continue the discussion.

Fond regards.
thomascrosthwaite
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 11:54 am
@Ann cv,
Once again Mr. Campbell is trying to create evidence where there isn't any. Revelations chapters 1 through 9 is about the seven churches in Asia, and you have to read all nine chapters to understand the context, if it can be understood at all. Why is Chapter 8 verse 8 any different from from the rest of the wild predictions made in Chapters 8 and 9? Also, Mr. Campbell forgot to tell us that four angels stood on the four corners of the Earth in Rev. 7 verse 1. Learning,Speech,&Attention Defects | Man with learning disabilities, communication disorders, ADHD, becomes author
0 Replies
 
Campbell34
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 03:12 pm
@Adam Bing,
Adam Bing;42598 wrote:
Mr.Campbell, so are you saying that Deutoronomy is no longer relevant? Because you say you'd kill me if we lived back in the time of Deutoronomy.

I take it then, that you won't kill me now because you feel that Deutoronomy is not relevant in today's world.

You and I Sir, are in perfect agreement then. We have had a meeting of the minds on the fact that the Bible is not relevant in today's world.

But do feel free to retract what you said and we can continue the discussion.

Many of the stories given in the Old Testament were given to show that trying to serve God by the law alone was impossible. These stories were given to us for examples, and they show us the weakness of a life based only on a law. Now today Christians donot put their hope of eternal salvation on the Law, but rather on the finished work of Jesus Christ. And because some of the stories of the Old Testament now are but examples, this in no way makes the entire Old Testament not relevant. The Bible tells us all Scripture is to be used for instruction. The Old Testament is still necessary especially when one considers the prophecies that still remain, and are in the process of being fulfilled. Of course to say that the Bible is not relevant in todays world would require one to be totally ignorant of those prophecies. You must also remember, the Old Testament is the Old Covenant, and the New testament is the New Covenant which Christians now follow.
aaronssongs
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 03:42 pm
@Campbell34,
Campbell34;42590 wrote:
Well if we lived back in the time of Deutoronomy and you were one of those unbelievers God told me to kill, I would. And it would not be murder because murder is killing without cause. In this case, I would be doing what the Creator of the Universe told me to do. And God never has anyone do such a thing, unless there is a very good reason for it. When you get to know God, you understand that everything He tells you to do is for the good. And sometimes you don't see it that way, but I got to tell you, God sure has a way about getting His believers to do the right thing. I recall going with a woman 30 years ago before I met my wife. I was going to ask her to marry me, but this woman forgot to tell me she was all ready engaged to this 23 year old guy and soon became his third wife. I wrote her a letter and told her what I though about her when I found out. Would you believe, Just this year God forced me to apologize to her. God has good reasons for doing what He does even if we don't understand them.


You're quite ill...God gave us 'free will'...he didn't force you to do anything...the voices talking to you in your head, aren't the voice of God...you're delusional, and need to seek help.
Campbell34
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 03:43 pm
@Numpty,
Numpty;42594 wrote:
God forced you to apologise? Ol' Gods seems to be somewhat of a meglomaniac.

As you said something LIKE a mountain of burning fire. When a piece of fiction is written, the writer is given artistic license to expand and exaggerate to the story they are telling. They may not know of Asteriods but you can bet yer bottom dollar they have heard of ,or seen Volcanoes spewing out lava and burning rocks into the atmosphere. How easy is it then to exaggerate that knowledge to something LIKE the size of a mountain.

Your Prophecies can be accounted for using probability that an event will at some point occur. It's the same with Nostradamus, hundreds of prophicies fullfilled because people attach similaraities to generic propersitions. It is the same with the bible, I appreciate you think Nostradamus is as big a nut as i do, but the same can be said of what is written in the bible.


Yes you can rationalize away or stretch a story anyway you like, but John who is telling the story is saying he saw something the size of a mountain strike the sea with such force that is destroyed one third of the marine life, and a third of the ships in that sea. And of course your take is that John is just another liar, who is fabricating a falsehood. And of course you have to believe that, because to believe anything else might just put you in harms way spiritually.
I believe John, and I believe he is speaking the truth, and I believe all the prophecies of the Bible. The problem the non believers are having with these prophecies are they mirror what is happening in the world today. And because so many of these prophecies are so detailed, the arguement for probability becomes almost laughable. And Nostradamus is nothing more than a Jonny come lately, many of his prophecies are based on Biblical accounts and what he did not get from the Bible, he tried to get from occult practices.
Most of the writers of the Bible died for what they believed in, and I doubt any of them would of died for artistic license.
Numpty
 
  1  
Reply Sun 21 Oct, 2007 04:05 pm
@Campbell34,
Campbell34;42636 wrote:
Yes you can rationalize away or stretch a story anyway you like, but John who is telling the story is saying he saw something the size of a mountain strike the sea with such force that is destroyed one third of the marine life, and a third of the ships in that sea. And of course your take is that John is just another liar, who is fabricating a falsehood. And of course you have to believe that, because to believe anything else might just put you in harms way spiritually.
I believe John, and I believe he is speaking the truth, and I believe all the prophecies of the Bible. The problem the non believers are having with these prophecies are they mirror what is happening in the world today. And because so many of these prophecies are so detailed, the arguement for probability becomes almost laughable. And Nostradamus is nothing more than a Jonny come lately, many of his prophecies are based on Biblical accounts and what he did not get from the Bible, he tried to get from occult practices.
Most of the writers of the Bible died for what they believed in, and I doubt any of them would of died for artistic license.


Well I didn't say he was a liar. I guess we first need to prove he actually existed first before we can call him a liar. My opinion is whilst you can say the prophecies in the bible are coming true or have been proved true, it is also just as possible the stories were fabricated. By that I do not mean they were made to fool us or somehow lead us down the wrong path. Mearly that in order for a deity to be seen as mystical/ magical, the acts have to be seen to be unbelievable.

just an out there question. is there anything left or available of anything Jesus wrote, assuming he could write of course?


Take a chill pill, you do not seem to be taking this debating too well. At the end of the day none of us know what exactly going to happen, you/ I think we do, but we don't. We are expressing our opinions and debating our 'Conflicting views'. have a beer kick back and enjoy
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

 
Copyright © 2024 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.05 seconds on 05/21/2024 at 05:22:21