I love Myst - When I first started playing it, it was the most deliciously, eerie and suspenseful game. OH it was good. I like Battlefront (I play with my boys) and I like all of the Legos games - I know - childish - but I think they're fun! But I also like Scrabble and word base games too - puzzles as well.
I am a tom boy though...brought up in the midst of boys...not sure if that has any bearing on my love of video games or not.