Setanta wrote:At no time did i write anything even remotely resembling a claim that Lincoln was the first president to "bring up religion."
Let's roll the videotape:
Setanta, in the dimly remembered past (about six hours ago), wrote:Before Lincoln, Presidents and candidates were careful not to bring up religion...
QED
Setanta wrote:The post of mine to which you have most recently responded underlines my post prior to that, in which i wrote: "I know of no agent of government of the United States, let alone the President, who has established a religious holiday." Your reference to Washington's proclamation fails to fulfill that criterion.
How so? Just because Thanksgiving wasn't officially established by Washington as a national holiday
the next year? Sorry, but I wasn't aware that a holiday must be, by definition, an annual event.
Anyway, from Lincoln's Oct. 1863 proclamation, it's clear that even
he didn't contemplate his thanksgiving celebration to be an annual thing. After all, he had also issued thanksgiving proclamations in the spring of 1862 and in the spring of 1863. It only became an autumnal tradition when Lincoln issued a thanksgiving proclamation in 1864 for the same day -- the last Thursday in November. After that, the tradition was extended as much as a tribute to Lincoln as it was to an almighty and beneficent deity.