@mysteryman,
mysteryman wrote:
I have to agree with Cyclo (I know, what a shock).
The plan you have stated does no good if someone cant afford to buy insurance in the first place.
All of the tax deductions in the world wont allow someone to buy something they dont have the money up front for.
But what Ican didn't say in that single post, and what Cyclop almost never admits, is that tax policy can and does change the dynamics of how people manage their money and what they spend it on. And it can change the dynamics of the market to make some things more affordable, some things less affordable, and some things more or less attractive.
Those who can't afford healthcare insurance period are being mostly taken care of by government programs. But the way to make healthcare more affordable is not to force people into a vaguely defined, poorly thought out, and probably incompetently managed government system. The best way to make healthcare more affordable is to change the system that drives healthcare costs up, and a lot of that the government can control since it was their policies that created most of it.
Ican has correctly suggested that the simple idea of focusing on the uninsured and it would be far less costly to deal with rather than dismantling the entire system that would very likely eventually force everybody into something else.