I've been checking in here to see if Bree posted a question. IT'S MY TURN. What does that say about me!
Same theme:
1. Peter Finch (One word from title) + Matt Dillon (One word from title)
2. Shelley Winters (One word from title) + Ryan O'Neal (One word from title)
3. Peter O'Toole (Two words from Title) + Matt Dillon (One word from title)
4. Katharine Hepburn (One word title)
5. Fred Astaire (Two words from title) + Burt Lancaster (Two words from title)