Re: The most liberal Christmas song in the world
flaja wrote:The Christmas song "Do You Hear What I Hear" has a line to the effect that there is a child shivering in the cold, let us bring Him silver and gold.
That is the quintessential liberal solution to a socio-economic problem that government policy had caused to begin with- throw money at it.
Extract from Wikipedia.
One of the co-writers of this song was - " born Leon Schlienger in 1922. He may have been born Jewish: Leo or Leon is a popular Westernization of the Hebrew name Lev. His adopted names are almost the palindromes of his birth names. Noel, of course, means Christmas; Regney may be a play on the French verb "regner," to reign. In other words, "Christmas Reign," which raises the question of whether he changed his names to pass as Christian for safety, or whether he was a genuine convert. He was drafted into the Nazi army despite being a Frenchman. Presumably, as an Alsatian, he would have spoken German as fluently as French. It is said that he soon deserted, joined a group of French Resistance fighters, and became a double agent working for the French. He led a party of Nazis into an ambush and was shot, but survived and eventually lived in New York City."
I don't know about you, but I reckon that a guy who'd experienced what he did during his youth, was quite entitled to write a pleasant, catchy song about Christmas, whether he doodled it just to make bucks or not.
A lot of people like that song, even theough it's obviously not a musical masterpiece by any stretch of the imagination.
If, some years later, some person with waaay too much time on their hands wants to pick it apart in order to bring a very tenuous political argument into the equation, then I would recommend that they put that nitpicking time to better use in future and go do some charity work in somewhere like a soup kitchen.
Not only would they get out and see some real life, but they
may end up feeling better about where they fit in, and what they are contributing to, our modern day society.
Sheesh!