Reply
Fri 31 Aug, 2007 03:20 pm
Sentence:
The way relevance theory accounts for such "loose talk" is by claiming that the relationship between what we say and the thoughts we intend to communicate is one of interpretive resemblance - the thoughts we intend to communicate is one of interpretive resemblance - in other words, we do not necessarily say what we think, but more often than not what we say interpretively resembles what we intend to communicate.
My trouble:
I can't read it, especially the latter part of it containing "more often than not what". (I checked, and it seems that I correctly typed what appears on my book.)
So could you please paraphrase it?
Thanks in advance!
Bluestblue--
Your quote is the sort of prose that I dislike.
A rough paraphrase would be, "I'll tell you what I want you to know. (This is not necessarily either what you need to know or a description of the way the world really is.)"
Noddy, when I read it I get more of something like this:
"When we talk, our words do not exactly convey our thoughts. However, the hearer is usually able to interpret our meaning."
The talk is "loose" because it is not an exact transcription of our thoughts. The interpretation is possible because of the resemblance between what we say and the thoughts we mean to communicate.
Bluestblue, perhaps the correct meaning can be deduced from the surrounding text.
(Better punctuation would have helped that sentence: "...in other words, we do not necessarily say what we think; but more often than not, what we say interpretively resembles what we intend to communicate.")
Wy--
I let my biases get in the way. Your reading is much more accurate than mine.
Thanks a lot for your helpful explanations.
Blues
Wy wrote:
(Better punctuation would have helped that sentence: "...in other words, we do not necessarily say what we think; but more often than not, what we say interpretively resembles what we intend to communicate.")
Exactly. The thing is, more and more writers are omitting commas and semicolons that tend to help clarify long sentences made up of many clauses.