@brianjakub,
Nei is certainly entitled to his opinions but its fairly obvious that (even by the neutral "theorists") selection occurs at all levels, cellular to organismal and is accomplished as a physiological "tropism" by mostly external agents.
Ascribing "ID" to given chemical reactions is kinda lame thinking on ID's behalf. I know they are merely trying to insert a deity in the mix but they seem to deny that Oxidation/Reduction is intelligence-free to make it happen, further dont ALL surface reactions happen blindly in nature whether its just mere adsorption, hydrolysis, linkages or a whole bag of reactions. Why do they need some overseer?? (I really think the MAGIC occurred over 10 billion years ago when , after the Big Bang, which only created Hydrogen and helium, how the heavy elements got produced)
Youre still obviously flopping around looking for a landing .I can see youve not read any of the Sean Carroll book that I suggested to you several months back (Making of the Fittest). Otherwise youd have seen my clip of my early ridiculing of the Biochemistry of ID. I think I also told Leadfoot and I believe he actually caught up with it.
Evolution , on the whole, is an interaction of mutation (not redesign from scratch), natural selection, and Time. ID "hypothesists" scramble about by trying to dispute and deny one of these components. The overall evidence, like Dr Behes writings and testimony on "Irreducible Complexity" stand in evidence totally against His writings. (Still, he is a featured scholar and a board member of the Discovery Institute the USA center of science denial on evolution by nat selection).