Reply
Wed 25 Oct, 2006 07:04 am
Lately hundreds of US journalists and reporters sent to Iraq have had to deal with attempts by the US military to control information. Now not only many in military blame the press for presenting independent data about what is happening in Iraq. Some members of US Congress begin also severely criticize our press for dwelling on bombing damage to civilian areas and the suffering of the Iraqi people. Take, for example, the last show of CNN video about present Iraq in the US Congress, after which the chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, Republican Congressman H. Duncan has proposed "to inhibit CNN journalists from moraling operations of Iraqi adversary forces". But what about the freedom of speech in our democratic society? Americans want to know the whole truth about the war in Iraq! But for such independent observations of Iraqi events we should never have known about our real losses there or about such disreputable facts as Abu Ghraib or CIA secret prisons! The Pentagon and the White House always try to hold back the truth about it, sheltering behind the phrase that "our enemies are also watching CNN-TV". But why cannot the whole world, including the enemy, see the reports of independent journalists, as it was during World War II or Vietnam War, when the press was able to broadcast directly from the battlefield? Free press, like CNN, should always have access to a war zone, because all Americans have a right to know what is really happening in Iraq. Otherwise our authorities will violate the First Amendment guarantee freedom of the press!
This has been the trend since Vietnam. The press, by allowing the public to know the details of the war, was blamed for its unpopularity. Now, with controlled information, public opinion is more easily manipulated in favor of the ones in power.
Walter Cronkite has indicated that the high point in his career came during a documentary he did in 1972 about the Vietnam War, when he indicated that the war was unwinnable. In an interview with the Orlando Sentinel, Cronkite said, "I came to the conclusion that we should get out of Vietnam. Some, at least, believe that the resulting opinion I expressed had some effect on the end of the war." (It was later reported that following the broadcast, President Lyndon Johnson remarked to an aide: "If we've lost Walter, we've lost the American people.")
I read yesterday that there are currently 9 journalists embedded in Iraq right now. Just nine. Many more cannot get cleared to go, and bloggers aren't allowed at all.
IIRC, the pentagon changed the rules during GW1... the truth is that noone knows what the hell is going on in Iraq.
Cycloptichorn