kate4christ03 wrote:JPB when i said "hate torture kill" i was using kill in the context of those that were first discussed at the beginning of this thread ...that believe that we are justified to kill (murder) those that believe differently .......ie rudolph blowing up the abortion clinic and killing a security guard....or the rcc killing ppl who didnt believe as they did during the inquisition.....
Kate, the problem with christians not acknowledging that their fringe elements are also christian and with muslims not acknowledging that their extremists are also representing Islam is that the rest of us have no option but to lump the good in with the bad. You can't simply turn away from your own membership because they don't represent your personal thoughts and expect society to do the same. Fringe elements must be dealt with from within the group, not ignored. They don't go away and you don't get to decide for the world who is and isn't part of your club. This applies to any religion.
If moderate muslims want the world to see Islam as a peaceful religion then it is going to take the moderate muslims to change the image we all have of Islam by taking on their extremists. If christians want the world to see christianity as a loving religion then it's going to take loving christians to challenge those who don't represent that philosophy. In the eyes of the world, christians today are fundamentalist hypocrites who want nothing other than to eliminate anyone who disagrees with them. Many, if not most, people have the same view of Islam. Saying they aren't 'true christians' doesn't change anything. Of course they're true christians. Of course muslim extremists are true muslims. The perception of the group is the responsibility of the group.
Saying that the RCCs during the Inquisition weren't christians is ludicrous. You can't rewrite history, Kate, and claim that actions done in the name of the church weren't done by christians because you wish it to be so. This is the most ridiculous claim I've ever seen.