Thomas wrote:527s are independent civic organizations. If some liberal activists wanted to start up a Swiftboat-like organization against McCain, Obama would have no power to prevent them. At best, he could let them carry out their smears and apologize later if necessary. Kind of like he did when his people denied seats to Muslim women with headscarfs.
So how can 527s be part of any enforceable agreement between two presidential candidates? They can't. They just serve as a convenient pretense for Obama to break his own deal.
As a matter of fact, it is illegal for candidates to communicate with 527s, and so Obama's contention that McCain should be putting a stop to conservative 527s is disingenuous at best.
Just this afternoon Mechelle Williams of NPR interviewed a pundit from politico.com on this very subject. As much as she clearly wanted her guest to confirm Obama's malarky about 527s, he refused to cooperate.
Instead he made the very clear point that currently there is virtually no conservative 527 activity which he attributed, in part, to McCain's expressed displeasure with the format.
To be fair, he also suggested that Obama is of a similar mind, but acknowledged that MoveOn.com is spending quite a lot of money (whether as a 527 or a PAC) attacking McCain.
Of course the discussion inevitably found its way to the Swift Boaters of 2004, but the guest had a very interesting observation which, not surprisingly, has gotten very little play in the Media: Democratic 527s in 2004 outspent the Swift Boaters by a very sizable margin, but were no where near as effective.
So no matter what one thinks of 527s and the Swift Boaters, the actual lesson of 2004 is the the Democrats tried the same approach, outspent their rivals, but were far less effective. Never-the-less we are left, thanks to the liberal biased Media, with the generally accepted notion that particulary noxious GOP 527s decided the 2004 election.
Obama made the politically wise decision to forgo public funding. As a result he will get to outspend McCain by around 2 to 1.
He also took the tried and true political approach of blaming anything and everything (including his own actions) on his opponent.
In any other race we might all be marvelling at his political accumen, but, of course, in this one he has promised not to engage in such Old Political tactics.
It is amusing to see how his fervent followers justify this clear break with his promises, but each time he reveals himself to be nothing more or less than a good old fashioned American politician, he shakes, if not repels, the interest of moderates and independents.
The irony is that McCain, while no political lamb himself, actually takes this stuff seriously and is liable to sink his own campaign because he will not engage in a bare knuckle fight with his opponent.
With each passing week we can see more and more evidence that Obama is nothing more than a Chicago politician...without the experience of his elders.