Cycloptichorn wrote:woiyo wrote:"it's hard to imagine McCain ever being an inspirational figure."
A highly decorated Navy Office, former POW, distinguished leader in the US Senate.
You may not find these "inspirational, but I am sure many will.
He has past accomplishments - nobody denies that.
But 'inspirational?' Let me ask you, what about his message do you find inspirational?
Cycloptichorn
Some people are more inspired by deeds than words - particularly actions that are difficult, taken under conditions of extreme stress and involving high consequences for the person himself and for others as well. Such deeds that may, in particular, be indicative of traits (say of courage or the ability to deal in a principled way with critical and important issues) have great power to inspire others -- particularly in challenging times.
His comments about "message" suggest that Cyclo may be of another type, or guided by different things = one who most values words and statments of somewhat abstract values and principles, and one who, perhaps due to a lack of experience of the uncertainty of things in life and of the frequently encountered inability of gifted communicators to live up to their soaring words in the real world, undervalues the significance of challenging deeds that indicate the presence of precisely the character traits needed to accomplish the very same things Cyclo has in mind.
The ability to persuasively articulate a needed political message is rare enough. The strength of character to persist in the things required to bring the message to life is even rarer - and sadly does not often corelate well with the ability to communicate it.
I'll grant that communication skills are important in the political process, and that Obama has also shown other traits, notably a degree of wisdom and restraint that are very important as well. However as Nicias spoke to the Athenian electors at the start of the Third Peloponesian war, -- "It generally is not wise for the fathers and guardians of the state to put all their trust, and the fate of the city, in the hands of a young man in a hurry, even one so persuasive and gifted as Alcibiades here."