Butrflynet wrote:Nimh, have you looked at the two websites side by side? Can you honestly say they have an "uncanny resemblance?"
I must admit I hadnt. "Uncanny resemblance" definitely looks like an exaggeration - I cant see much of a resemblance except for perhaps the colour scheme.
(Then again, I'm mostly 'cleaning out my archive' here, and the item is from a week ago, so who knows, they might just have changed the webpage after the controversy. Should have posted it at the time.)
Sozobe wrote:A lot of the criticism of Edwards' 527 ads was that the 527 was run by Edwards' former campaign manager. It wasn't just that it was a 527, it was that it was difficult to believe that it wasn't coordinating with Edwards' campaign at all.
Hhmmmm... it may not have been
just that, but at the time Obama was attacking him just for the 527 issue per se in no uncertain words as well. Here, from the article you quote:
"John said yesterday, he didn't believe in these 527s," Obama said on Dec. 22 in Iowa. "You can't say yesterday, you don't believe in it and today three-quarters of a million dollars is being spent for you. You can't just talk the talk."
That's not, "well it's not just that you have a 527 campaigning for you, it's that it's run by etc." That's pretty clearly: 527s = bad.
Also, why is it inherently "difficult to believe" that this 527 wasn't coordinating with Edwards' campaign, because it was run by a former Edwards campaign manager? Former campaign managers have to do something in the next elections as well, and it would stand to reason that they still sympathise with the same guys. Not saying that it shouldnt have raised
questions - it's a tricky enough constellation to warrant 'em. But I wonder what your response would have been if, say, Obama's former campaigner from when he was running for Senate was now leading a 527 effort supporting him. I'm guessing it might be similar to what I just wrote.
Sozobe wrote:Obama's campaign on Friday released a letter dated Dec. 28 written to Phillips by his campaign lawyer, Robert Bauer, asking Phillips to stop their efforts to help Obama.
"And independent effort such as yours ... is simply not consistent with the senator's clearly stated commitment to complete accountability and transparency in the financing of campaigns for public office," Bauer wrote.
OK, roger. Thanks for the update!