@mysteryman,
mysteryman wrote:
You couldnt have watched the video AND looked at the graph I linked to in one minute, but I will try to explain.
You're right, I didn't give a **** about the video. Just read the blog.
The link to the graph didn't work.
Quote:Nancy Pelosi blamed Bush and Cheney for the rise in gas prices, saying that it was the fault of the "2 oil men" in the WH.
Now, prices have almost tripled since Obama became POTUS.
So, using her logic, the fault lies with the "2 oil men" in the WH.
Actually, that's terribly incorrect. And has nothing to do with logic at all. When you say 'using her logic,' you aren't describing her logic, but instead what she said. That's not the same thing.
I'll give you an example:
Let's say a house burns down. When asked 'why did the house burn down,' you say 'well, the owners left a candle burning, and it started a fire.'
Next week a different house burns down. When asked, I say 'Well, by MM's logic, the owners must have left a candle burning and it started a fire.'
Never mind the fact that this isn't the case, by YOUR logic, your pronouncement of causation in one case leads to you pronouncing that to be the cause of all similar cases. Which I think you can agree isn't true at all.
I see what you are getting at here, of course; but your point is failing. If you want to show that Pelosi is a hypocrite, you'll have to do somewhat better than this.
Cycloptichorn